Shelter Island Luxury Real Estate

Listings last updated 12/01/2021
    • 3 BedsBds
    • 2 BathsBa
    • 2,100 SqftSqft
    • 2.96 ac Lot Size
    • Residential
    Map
    $6,400,000 USD
    • 5 BedsBds
    • 5 BathsBa
    • 5,770 SqftSqft
    • 2.3 ac Lot Size
    • Residential
    Map
    $5,950,000 USD
    • 6 BedsBds
    • 6 BathsBa
    • 4,407 SqftSqft
    • 1.8 ac Lot Size
    • Residential
    Map
    $2,995,000 USD
    • 6 BedsBds
    • 6 BathsBa
    • 4,407 SqftSqft
    • 1.8 ac Lot Size
    • Residential
    Map
    $2,995,000 USD
    • 3 BedsBds
    • 4 BathsBa
    • 1,824 SqftSqft
    • 2.2 ac Lot Size
    • Residential
    Map
    $2,925,000 USD
    • 4 BedsBds
    • 3 BathsBa
    • 2,286 SqftSqft
    • 1.19 ac Lot Size
    • Residential
    Map
    $2,600,000 USD
    • 3 BedsBds
    • 2 BathsBa
    • 1,451 SqftSqft
    • 0.9 ac Lot Size
    • Residential
    Map
    $1,150,000 USD
  • Get price drops notifications & new listings right in your inbox!

Only 12 listings are available in Shelter Island. Below you can find luxury real estate from nearby areas in Suffolk County:

    • 12 BedsBds
    • 8 BathsBa
    • 5,000 SqftSqft
    • 2.08 ac Lot Size
    • Residential
    Map
    $48,000,000 USD
    • 5.18 ac Lot Size
    • Residential
    Map
    $44,950,000 USD
    • 6 BedsBds
    • 8 BathsBa
    • 5,000 SqftSqft
    • 3 ac Lot Size
    • Residential
    Map
    $39,500,000 USD
    • 11 BedsBds
    • 13 BathsBa
    • 11,892 SqftSqft
    • 1.4 ac Lot Size
    • Residential
    Map
    $37,995,000 USD
    • 6 BedsBds
    • 7 BathsBa
    • 5,152 SqftSqft
    • 4.4 ac Lot Size
    • Residential
    Map
    $35,000,000 USD
    • 11 BedsBds
    • 13 BathsBa
    • 14,000 SqftSqft
    • 3 ac Lot Size
    • Residential
    Map
    $35,000,000 USD
    • 9 BedsBds
    • 11 BathsBa
    • 11,000 SqftSqft
    • House
    Open House
    Tue, 7 December 12:00 PM to 2:00 PM
    Please follow the guidance of local authorities when deciding on a property viewing during COVID-19.
    Map
    $33,950,000 USD
    • 14 BedsBds
    • 20 BathsBa
    • 16,000 SqftSqft
    • 3.25 ac Lot Size
    • Residential
    Map
    $28,800,000 USD
12 Results
adplus-dvertising