Sq Ft
 - 
Sq Ft
AC
 - 
AC
 - 

    Cincinnatus, NY Real Estate & Homes for Sale

    Listings last updated 09/22/2022

    24 Homes Available

    • 5091 Dutch Hill Road, Cincinnatus, NY 13040

      • 2 BedsBds
      • 2 BathsBa
      • 960 SqftSqft
      • 2.22 ac Lot Size
      • Residential
      Map
      $119,900 USD
      View Details

    • 5836 McFarlane Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040

      • 4 BedsBds
      • 2 BathsBa
      • 2,170 SqftSqft
      • 55.21 ac Lot Size
      • Residential
      Map
      $369,900 USD
      View Details

    • 1297 Morey Hill Road, Cincinnatus, NY 13040

      • 1 BedBd
      • 1 BathBa
      • 896 SqftSqft
      • 0.5 ac Lot Size
      • Residential
      Map
      $35,999 USD 4K
      View Details

    • 1149 Johnson Road, Cincinnatus, NY 13040

      • 3 BedsBds
      • 2 BathsBa
      • 1,416 SqftSqft
      • 101.95 ac Lot Size
      • Residential
      Map
      $364,900 USD
      View Details

    • 2423 Stafford Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040

      • 3 BedsBds
      • 3 BathsBa
      • 2,800 SqftSqft
      • 2.17 ac Lot Size
      • Residential
      Map
      $399,000 USD
      View Details
    10 Results
    Save this search to find out first when new listings & price drops are posted in this area or check out nearby properties that match your criteria.

    Nearby Homes matching your search criteria

    Results within 5 miles

    Results within 10 miles

    • 14 Bradford Street, Marathon, NY 13803

      • 4 BedsBds
      • 3 BathsBa
      • 2,424 SqftSqft
      • 0.253 ac Lot Size
      • Residential
      Map
      $239,900 USD
      View Details

    • 1077 State Route 26, Willet, NY 13863

      • 2 BedsBds
      • 1 BathBa
      • 632 SqftSqft
      • 1.18 ac Lot Size
      • Residential
      Map
      $99,900 USD
      View Details

    • 269 County Road 10, Pharsalia, NY 13801

      • 3 BedsBds
      • 2 BathsBa
      • 1,568 SqftSqft
      • 1 ac Lot Size
      • Residential
      Map
      $149,900 USD
      View Details

    • 163 Pitcher Springs Road, Pitcher, NY 13136

      • 3 BedsBds
      • 1 BathBa
      • 1,960 SqftSqft
      • 0.83 ac Lot Size
      • Residential
      Map
      $29,990 USD
      View Details

    • 8 W Academy Street, McGraw, NY 13101

      • 3 BedsBds
      • 2 BathsBa
      • 1,584 SqftSqft
      • 0.28 ac Lot Size
      • Residential
      Map
      $179,900 USD
      View Details

    • 1283 State Highway 26, Pitcher, NY 13155

      • 4 BedsBds
      • 2 BathsBa
      • 1,935 SqftSqft
      • 1 ac Lot Size
      • Residential
      Map
      $110,000 USD
      View Details

    • 108 County Road 7, McDonough, NY 13801

      • 6 BedsBds
      • 1 BathBa
      • 3,172 SqftSqft
      • 1 ac Lot Size
      • Residential
      Map
      $40,000 USD
      View Details
    Finding homes for sale in Cincinnatus, NY has never been easier as our comprehensive directory currently contains more than 24 listings! With prices for houses for sale in Cincinnatus, NY starting as low as $35,999, we make the search for the perfect home easy by providing you with the right tools!

    Nearby Cities

    More Search Options

    Real Estate Experts in Cincinnatus, NY