Shelter Island Heights Real Estate

Listings last updated 04/30/2021
  • See more in: 11965
    • 5 BedsBds
    • 3 BathsBa
    • 1,802 SqftSqft
    • 0.81 ac Lot Size
    • Residential
    Map
    $3,250,000 USD
  • See more in: 11965
    • 5 BedsBds
    • 3 BathsBa
    • 4,220 SqftSqft
    • 0.7 ac Lot Size
    • Residential
    Map
    $2,995,000 USD
  • See more in: 11965
    • 7 BedsBds
    • 7 BathsBa
    • 4,941 SqftSqft
    • 2.2 ac Lot Size
    • Residential
    Map
    $8,000,000 USD
  • See more in: 11965
    • 5 BedsBds
    • 4 BathsBa
    • 3,350 SqftSqft
    • 0.54 ac Lot Size
    • Residential
    Map
    $1,495,000 USD

Only 9 listings are available in Shelter Island Heights. Below you can find real estate from nearby areas in Suffolk County:

  • See more in: 11946
    • 3 BedsBds
    • 3 BathsBa
    • 2,008 SqftSqft
    • 0.39 ac Lot Size
    • Residential
    Map
    $1,650,000 USD
  • See more in: 11951
    • 3 BedsBds
    • 2 BathsBa
    • 0.23 ac Lot Size
    • Residential
    Open House
    Sat, 15 May 11:00 AM to 1:00 PM
    Please follow the guidance of local authorities when deciding on a property viewing during COVID-19.
    Map
    $339,900 USD
  • See more in: 11933
    • 3 BedsBds
    • 2 BathsBa
    • 0.92 ac Lot Size
    • Residential
    Map
    $569,990 USD
  • See more in: 11953
    • 2 BedsBds
    • 1 BathBa
    • 1,032 SqftSqft
    • 0.5 ac Lot Size
    • Residential
    Map
    $250,000 USD
  • See more in: 11733
    • 4 BedsBds
    • 4 BathsBa
    • 0.69 ac Lot Size
    • Residential
    $1,040,000 USD
  • See more in: 11720
    • 3 BedsBds
    • 2 BathsBa
    • 0.23 ac Lot Size
    • Residential
    Map
    $385,000 USD
  • See more in: 11784
    • 4 BedsBds
    • 3 BathsBa
    • 0.13 ac Lot Size
    • Residential
    $389,000 USD
  • See more in: 11930
    • 2 BedsBds
    • 1 BathBa
    • 0.22 ac Lot Size
    • Residential
    Map
    $990,000 USD
  • See more in: 11770
    • 4 BedsBds
    • 3 BathsBa
    • 0.09 ac Lot Size
    • Residential
    Map
    $1,100,000 USD
  • See more in: 11795
    • 3 BedsBds
    • 1 BathBa
    • 0.21 ac Lot Size
    • Residential
    Map
    $415,000 USD
  • See more in: 11763
    • 3 BedsBds
    • 2 BathsBa
    • 609 SqftSqft
    • 0.01 ac Lot Size
    • Residential
    Open House
    Sun, 16 May 12:30 PM to 2:00 PM
    Please follow the guidance of local authorities when deciding on a property viewing during COVID-19.
    Map
    $339,000 USD
  • See more in: 11743
    • 3 BedsBds
    • 2 BathsBa
    • 0.12 ac Lot Size
    • Residential
    Map
    $589,000 USD
  • See more in: 11733
    • 5 BedsBds
    • 4 BathsBa
    • 3,500 SqftSqft
    • 1.06 ac Lot Size
    • Residential
    Map
    $1,295,000 USD
9 Results
Finding homes for sale in Shelter Island Heights, NY has never been easier as our comprehensive directory currently contains more than 9 listings! With prices for houses for sale in Shelter Island Heights, NY starting as low as $1,495,000, we make the search for the perfect home easy by providing you with the right tools!