Shelter Island, NY Homes for Sale & Real Estate
2 Beds Bds
2 Baths Ba
1,435 Sqft Sqft
1.4 ac Lot Size
Residential
Sun, 28 May
12:00 PM to 1:00 PM
3 Beds Bds
2 Baths Ba
1,200 Sqft Sqft
0.5 ac Lot Size
Residential
3 Beds Bds
2 Baths Ba
1,421 Sqft Sqft
0.34 ac Lot Size
Residential
3 Beds Bds
2 Baths Ba
1,250 Sqft Sqft
1.12 ac Lot Size
Residential
1.6 ac Lot Size
Lots And Land
3 Beds Bds
2 Baths Ba
1,200 Sqft Sqft
0.5 ac Lot Size
Residential
3.1 ac Lot Size
Lots And Land
1.9 ac Lot Size
Lots And Land
8.45 ac Lot Size
Lots And Land
0.76 ac Lot Size
Lots And Land
3 Beds Bds
1 Bath Ba
900 Sqft Sqft
Residential
4 ac Lot Size
Lots And Land
3 Beds Bds
4 Baths Ba
4,478 Sqft Sqft
8.45 ac Lot Size
Residential
1.26 ac Lot Size
Lots And Land
6 Beds Bds
8 Baths Ba
6,000 Sqft Sqft
3.4 ac Lot Size
Residential
1.16 ac Lot Size
Lots And Land
Get price drops notifications & new listings right in your inbox!
Save this search now
6 ac Lot Size
Lots And Land
3 Beds Bds
2 Baths Ba
1,421 Sqft Sqft
0.34 ac Lot Size
Residential
Results within 2 miles
4 Beds Bds
7 Baths Ba
6,000 Sqft Sqft
2 ac Lot Size
Residential
4 Beds Bds
7 Baths Ba
6,000 Sqft Sqft
4 ac Lot Size
Residential
Results within 5 miles
6 Beds Bds
4 Baths Ba
2,400 Sqft Sqft
0.49 ac Lot Size
Residential
Sun, 28 May
12:00 PM to 1:30 PM
3 Beds Bds
3 Baths Ba
0.37 ac Lot Size
Residential
Mon, 29 May
1:00 PM to 2:30 PM
1 Bed Bd
1 Bath Ba
Residential
Sat, 27 May
1:00 PM to 3:00 PM
2 Beds Bds
1 Bath Ba
1,026 Sqft Sqft
0.28 ac Lot Size
Residential
1 - 24 of 24 Results
Finding homes for sale in Shelter Island, NY has never been easier as our comprehensive directory currently contains more than 24 listings! With prices for houses for sale in Shelter Island, NY starting as low as $588,000, we make the search for the perfect home easy by providing you with the right tools!
Nearby Cities
More Search Options
