Shelter Island Real Estate

Listings last updated 12/01/2021
    • 4 BedsBds
    • 3 BathsBa
    • 2,286 SqftSqft
    • 1.19 ac Lot Size
    • Residential
    Map
    $2,600,000 USD
    • 3 BedsBds
    • 2 BathsBa
    • 1,451 SqftSqft
    • 0.9 ac Lot Size
    • Residential
    Map
    $1,150,000 USD
    • 3 BedsBds
    • 2 BathsBa
    • 2,100 SqftSqft
    • 2.96 ac Lot Size
    • Residential
    Map
    $6,400,000 USD
    • 5 BedsBds
    • 5 BathsBa
    • 5,770 SqftSqft
    • 2.3 ac Lot Size
    • Residential
    Map
    $5,950,000 USD
    • 3 BedsBds
    • 4 BathsBa
    • 1,824 SqftSqft
    • 2.2 ac Lot Size
    • Residential
    Map
    $2,925,000 USD
    • 6 BedsBds
    • 6 BathsBa
    • 4,407 SqftSqft
    • 1.8 ac Lot Size
    • Residential
    Map
    $2,995,000 USD
    • 6 BedsBds
    • 6 BathsBa
    • 4,407 SqftSqft
    • 1.8 ac Lot Size
    • Residential
    Map
    $2,995,000 USD
  • Get price drops notifications & new listings right in your inbox!

Only 19 listings are available in Shelter Island. Below you can find real estate from nearby areas in Suffolk County:

    • 4 BedsBds
    • 2 BathsBa
    • 1,570 SqftSqft
    • 0.66 ac Lot Size
    • Residential
    Map
    $599,990 USD
    • 3 BedsBds
    • 2 BathsBa
    • 0.22 ac Lot Size
    • Residential
    Map
    $240,000 USD
    • 3 BedsBds
    • 2 BathsBa
    • 0.18 ac Lot Size
    • Residential
    Map
    $499,000 USD
    • 5 BedsBds
    • 3 BathsBa
    • 0.25 ac Lot Size
    • Residential
    Map
    $819,000 USD
19 Results
Finding homes for sale in Shelter Island, NY has never been easier as our comprehensive directory currently contains more than 19 listings! With prices for houses for sale in Shelter Island, NY starting as low as $995,000, we make the search for the perfect home easy by providing you with the right tools!
adplus-dvertising