For Sale

Mr. C's Ice Cream

86701 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL 33036

 

For the first time in 62 years Mr. C's Homemade Ice Cream is now being offered for sale representing a once-in-a-lifetime turnkey, legacy business. Located in one of the most highly visible shopping centers in Islamorada. Right across from Founders Park. This iconic, charming, and nostalgic ice cream shop has been a local favorite and a must-stop for visitors for over six decades. Everything is made in-house from the rich, creamy ice creams to the tropical gelatos and sorbets and signature waffle cones. This is a venture with a tremendous upside for a new owner ready to take it to the next level. Whether you're a hands-on operator, brand-builder, or investor seeking a location in the Keys with built-in cash flow and brand equity. The business name, FF&E, and recipes are included in the sale.

Want more info on this listing?

Reach out to the broker for more info on lease terms and amenities

Contacts

Greg Dully

RE/MAX All Keys Real Estate - Keys Connection Group

Curtis Skomp

RE/MAX Keys Connection

Building Details

  • For Sale $375,000
  • Property Type Unassigned
  • Property Size 931 SF
  • Lot Size 73,425 SF
  • # of Floors 1
  • Year Built 1991
  • Year Renovated 1995
  • Date Updated May 26, 2026

Getting Around

  • Walk Score ®

    Car-Dependent (28)

  • Bike Score ®

    Somewhat Bikeable (41)
Powered by Walk Score ®

Location

  • City Islamorada, FL
  • Zip Code 33036

Points of Interest

Mobil

4.93 miles

Chevron

5.05 miles

The Twisted Shrimps

1.12 miles

Hog Heaven Sports Bar and Grill

1.29 miles

88

1.37 miles

City Hall Cafe

1.65 miles

Lucky Twist

2.35 miles

Kindler

2.36 miles

Little Limon

2.36 miles

Tiki Bar

2.36 miles

Islamorada Pizza Co.

2.36 miles

Winn-Dixie

4.48 miles

Islamorada Volunteer Fire Department Station 2

1.32 miles

Monroe County Sheriff's Office Spottswood Substation

2.04 miles

Monroe County Sheriff's Office Upper Keys

2.13 miles

CVS Pharmacy

3.67 miles

Mariners Hospital

4.62 miles

Islamorada Volunteer Fire Department Station 1

4.65 miles

Tavernier Volunteer Fire Department

5.07 miles

Tavernier Volunteer Fire / Ambulance Department

5.72 miles

86701 Overseas Highway Listing Summary

  • What is the asking price at Mr. C's Ice Cream?

    Mr. C's Ice Cream is currently listed for sale at Contact for pricing.

  • What is the total size of Mr. C's Ice Cream?

    Mr. C's Ice Cream has a total of 931 square feet.

  • What is the year built for Mr. C's Ice Cream?

    The year built for Mr. C's Ice Cream is 1991.

Contact Mr. C's Ice Cream
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.