• Resources
    • Learning Center
    • Blog
Add a Listing Advertise
  • Property Lists
  • Listings
    • Commercial Real Estate
  • Comparables
  • Owners
  • Maps
  1. Commercial Properties
  2. CT
  3. New Haven
  • Details
  • Contacts
  • Location
  • POI
For Sale

433 Chapel St, 56 Wallace Street, and 64 Wallace Street

433 Chapel St, 56 Wallace Street, and 64 Wallace Street, New Haven, CT 06511

Located in the Mill River Area in the vibrant city of New Haven, this property offers a prime investment opportunity in a bustling commercial hub. Surrounding the area are renowned landmarks such as Yale University, renowned for its prestigious academic environment, and the Yale-New Haven Hospital, a leading medical institution. The district is also home to a variety of upscale dining options, chic boutiques, and cultural attractions, providing an enticing mix of amenities for potential tenants. With its strategic placement near major highways and public transportation, the property presents an ideal location for office or land investors seeking to capitalize on the dynamic energy and convenience of the urban landscape. Positioned near The Wooster Square Historic District it is an architecturally distinguished neighborhood located east of downtown New Haven. During the mid-19th century, it was a fashionable residential area which ship captains and wholesale grocers found convenient to their places of business and home of historically sought out destinations like Frank Pepe's and Sally's ApizzaDiscover a compelling investment opportunity with this historic property at 433 Chapel St. Boasting a 32,000 SF building, 1 unit, and a rich heritage dating back to 1870, this versatile space is ideal for innovative mixed-use concepts or land development. It is currently improved with a 6-story industrial/commercial building built in 1870 per town records containing 32,000 gross building square feet and 9,380 gross square feet of living area. The Highest and Best Use is concluded to be a conversion to apartments in conformance with applicable building codes. The condition of the improvements is rated fair. The building was called the M. Armstrong and Company Carriage Factory. The building was listed on the National Register of Historic Places on August 31, 2011, as a historic carriage factory. It is one of a small number of surviving 19th-century carriage factories in a city that once had more than 50 such businesses. Zoned IL, the property offers strategic potential for a range of commercial endeavors. Take advantage of this rare chance to acquire a distinctive property in the vibrant New Haven area, and unlock its full potential for your investment portfolio.

Key features

  • 32,000 SF building with potential for mixed-use development
  • Ideal for investment portfolio diversification
  • Prime location in the vibrant New Haven area
  • Rare opportunity to acquire a distinctive property with historical significance
  • Rich history dating back to 1870, adding unique character
  • Strategic potential for a range of commercial endeavors
  • Valuable package includes 56 & 65 Wallace St, enhancing scope
  • Zoned IL, offering flexibility for diverse commercial uses
Want more info on this listing?

Reach out to the broker for more info on lease terms and amenities

False

Contacts

broker
Paul Scalzo Sr.

Scalzo Commercial & New Development

Building Details

  • For Sale Subject To Offer
  • Property Type VacantLand
  • Property Size 9,380 SF
  • Units 1
  • Lot Size 0.59 Acre
  • Parking Spaces Avail. 43
  • Year Built 1870
  • Date Updated May 3, 2026

Attachments

  • Property Brochure 1 ()opens in new window
  • Property Brochure 2 ()opens in new window
  • Property Brochure 3 ()opens in new window

Getting Around

  • Walk Score ®

    Very Walkable (84)
  • Transit Score ®

    Good Transit (66)
  • Bike Score ®

    Biker's Paradise (90)
Powered by Walk Score ®

Location

  • City New Haven, CT
  • Neighborhood Mill River
  • Zip Code 06511
  • Market Bridgeport New Haven
  • Map
  • Street

Points of Interest

Ansonia

9.15 miles

Sunoco

0.67 miles

Mobil

0.90 miles

Citgo

0.92 miles

Shell

1.16 miles

BP

1.25 miles

Exxon

1.27 miles

Stop & Shop

1.59 miles

Best Gas

1.84 miles

Tesla Supercharger

3.94 miles

State-Adubon Parking

0.50 miles

Parcel E Lot

0.50 miles

State/Trumbull Parking Lot

0.51 miles

Lot 54

0.54 miles

State-Pulaski Lot

0.54 miles

Lot 32

0.57 miles

Lot O

0.62 miles

Ninth Square Public Parking

0.62 miles

Crown Street Lot

0.63 miles

Hertz

0.66 miles

Zipcar

0.83 miles

Speedy Wash

1.74 miles

Ultimate Car Wash

2.13 miles

Splash Car Wash

2.75 miles

Enterprise

4.01 miles

Splash

4.04 miles

Sponge Brothers Car Wash

4.38 miles

Automobilia Car Wash

4.99 miles

Pasta EATaliana

0.22 miles

Abaté

0.23 miles

Zeneli

0.25 miles

Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana

0.27 miles

Consiglio's

0.29 miles

Cody’s Diner

0.33 miles

Sally's Apizza

0.43 miles

Da Legna at Nolo

0.50 miles

Cast Iron Chef

0.53 miles

Elm City Market

0.60 miles

Million Asian Market

0.69 miles

La Supermarqueta

0.79 miles

Flynn’s Grocery

0.80 miles

C-Town

0.94 miles

Stop & Shop

1.51 miles

Minore's Market

1.86 miles

Edge of the Woods

1.98 miles

Xpect Deep Discounts

2.06 miles

Passport Health New Haven Travel Clinic

0.70 miles

Hancock Pharmacy

0.71 miles

CVS Pharmacy

0.71 miles

NHPD

0.75 miles

New Haven Police Department

0.75 miles

Rite Aid

0.77 miles

Fair Haven Substation

0.78 miles

Grand Medical

0.81 miles

Yale-New Haven Long Warf Medical Center

0.96 miles

433 Chapel St, 56 Wallace Street, and 64 Wallace Street Listing Summary

  • What is the asking price at 433 Chapel St, 56 Wallace Street, and 64 Wallace Street?

    The asking price for 433 Chapel St, 56 Wallace Street, and 64 Wallace Street is currently available on demand. Contact the listing broker for details.

  • What is the total size of 433 Chapel St, 56 Wallace Street, and 64 Wallace Street?

    433 Chapel St, 56 Wallace Street, and 64 Wallace Street has a total of 9,380 square feet.

  • What is the year built for 433 Chapel St, 56 Wallace Street, and 64 Wallace Street?

    The year built for 433 Chapel St, 56 Wallace Street, and 64 Wallace Street is 1870.

Contact Listing Broker
broker
Paul Scalzo Sr.

Scalzo Commercial & New Development

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Nearby Listings

Davenport & Congress Approved Development Site

Davenport & Congress Approved Development Site

326-384 Davenport Avenue & 859-879 Congress Avenue, New Haven, CT
Subject To Offer
Property
  • VacantLand
295 Beach Street

295 Beach Street

295 Beach Street, West Haven, CT
Subject To Offer
Property
  • VacantLand
49 Commercial Pkwy

49 Commercial Pkwy

49 Commercial Pkwy, Branford, CT
Contact for pricing
Property
  • VacantLand
  • 21.5 Acre
1219 W Main St

1219 W Main St

1219 W Main St, Branford, CT
$700,000
Property
  • VacantLand
  • 0.7 Acre
596-616 East Main Street

596-616 East Main Street

596-616 East Main Street, Branford, CT
$6,018,000
Property
  • VacantLand
  • 20.4 Acre

Popular Searches

  • New York City Office Properties for Sale
  • Manhattan Office Properties for Sale
  • Queens Office Properties for Sale
  • Brooklyn Office Properties for Sale
  • Bronx Office Properties for Sale
  • Fairfield Office Properties for Sale
  • Middletown Office Properties for Sale
  • Yonkers Office Properties for Sale
  • New York City Commercial Real Estate
  • Brooklyn Commercial Real Estate
  • Queens Commercial Real Estate
  • Manhattan Commercial Real Estate
  • Bronx Commercial Real Estate
  • Waterbury Commercial Real Estate
  • Newark Commercial Real Estate
  • Danbury Commercial Real Estate
  • Hartford Commercial Real Estate
  • Yonkers Commercial Real Estate
Copyright 2003-2026, PropertyShark.com
Contact Us  |  About  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms Of Service  |  Sitemaps