For Sale
234 N Main St
234 N Main St, Monticello, IN 47960
Positioned along North Main Street in downtown Monticello, the property sits within one of the area’s primary commercial and dining corridors. The downtown district is home to a variety of local shops, restaurants, bars, and service businesses, creating consistent activity and foot traffic throughout the year.
Monticello is widely known as a lake community, drawing seasonal visitors from across the region due to its proximity to Lake Shafer, Lake Freeman, and Indiana Beach. The area experiences increased tourism and recreational traffic during the spring and summer months, supporting local restaurants and entertainment businesses. The property’s walkable downtown location, visibility from Main Street, and established reputation make it an ideal setting for a restaurant/bar seeking both local and seasonal customer traffic.Located in the heart of downtown Monticello, Abe's Pizza presents a rare turnkey opportunity to own a long-established restaurant and bar location with strong local recognition and a proven presence in the community. Situated at 234 N Main St, the property is fully equipped for continued food and beverage operations and offers everything needed for a seamless transition to new ownership.
The space includes a fully built-out restaurant and bar setup, complete with a full commercial kitchen. All commercial kitchen equipment, restaurant and bar equipment, fixtures, and furniture are included in the sale price, creating an exceptional value for an owner-operator or investor seeking a ready-to-open concept.
The interior layout supports dine-in, carryout, and bar service, with a comfortable and functional flow for both customers and staff. Known locally for years as a destination for pizza and casual dining, the property benefits from strong name recognition and an established customer base within the Monticello community.
With its prominent Main Street presence, flexible setup, and included equipment package, the property is well-positioned for continued restaurant use or a new hospitality concept looking to capitalize on a highly visible downtown location.
Key features
- All restaurant equipment, bar equipment, fixtures, and furniture included in sale
- Established community presence and local name recognition
- Established restaurant and bar property
- Full commercial kitchen included
- Fully equipped turnkey opportunity
- Functional layout for dine-in, carryout, and bar service
- Ideal for restaurant, bar, brewery, café, or hospitality concept
- Prime downtown Main Street location
- Strong visibility with consistent foot and vehicle traffic
Want more info on this listing?
Reach out to the broker for more info on lease terms and amenities
False
Contacts
Emily Ginn
Shook Commercial Real Estate
Building Details
- For Sale $190,000
- Property Type Retail - Restaurant
- Property Size 4,895 SF
- Year Built 1975
- Date Updated May 15, 2026
Attachments
Getting Around
-
Walk Score ®
Somewhat Walkable (65) -
Bike Score ®
Bikeable (63)
Powered by Walk Score ®
Location
- City Monticello, IN
- Zip Code 47960
Points of Interest
Admiral Petroleum
0.60 miles
Kroger
0.68 miles
Sunoco
1.15 miles
Check-in parking
3.44 miles
Walmart Supercenter
1.02 miles
Stop & Shop
9.43 miles
234 N Main St Listing Summary
-
What is the asking price at 234 N Main St?
234 N Main St is currently listed for sale at Contact for pricing.
-
What is the total size of 234 N Main St?
234 N Main St has a total of 4,895 square feet.
-
What is the year built for 234 N Main St?
The year built for 234 N Main St is 1975.
Contact Listing Broker
Emily Ginn
Shook Commercial Real Estate