189 Fair St

For Sale

189 Fair St, Carmel, NY 10512

Discover the prime investment potential of Carmel, NY. Nestled in the heart of Putnam County, the area offers an attractive mix of suburban charm and urban convenience. With easy access to major transportation routes (Route 6, I-84), investors can capitalize on the desirability of the location for Multifamily property. Additionally, the bustling town center provides an array of dining, shopping, and entertainment options.Elevate your investment portfolio with this premier multifamily opportunity in Carmel, NY. This meticulously maintained 4,121 SF building, constructed in 2000, is zoned R and offers 4 spacious units, ideal for investor seeking ample space and contemporary amenities. The property's prime location in the thriving Carmel area ensures strong rental demand and promising returns. With its strategic positioning and modern construction, this multifamily gem presents a lucrative opportunity for investors looking to capitalize on the growing demand for high-quality residential accommodations in this sought-after locale.

Building Details

  • For Sale $799,000
  • Property Type Multi-Family
  • Property Size 4,121 SF
  • Units 4
  • Lot Size 2.51 Acre
  • Additional Rent Price on request
  • Building Class C
  • Year Built 2000
  • Date Updated Sep 22, 2026
View Attachment
Want more info on this listing?

Reach out to the broker for more info on lease terms and amenities

Contacts

Todd Albright

Princeton Realty Group

Location

  • City Carmel, NY
  • Neighborhood Carmel Hamlet
  • Zip Code 10512
  • Market White Plains
  • Walk score 3/100 Car-Dependent
  • Bike score 16/100 Somewhat Bikeable
Powered by Walk Score ®

Points of Interest

Croton Falls

6.05 miles

Purdy's

7.61 miles

Pawling

9.38 miles

Exxon

1.35 miles

BP

1.36 miles

Mobil

2.75 miles

Hess

4.05 miles

CITGO

4.24 miles

Shell

4.33 miles

Sunoco

5.21 miles

Fred Dill Wildlife Sanctuary

1.00 miles

yellow trail

1.39 miles

Putnam Trailway

1.48 miles

orange trail

1.53 miles

I-84 Exit 65 (Old Exit 19) Park & Ride

1.56 miles

Route 6 @ Tilly Foster Road

1.74 miles

Brewster Trailhead

2.27 miles

Clough Preserve Trailhead

2.63 miles

I-84 Exit 61 Park & Ride

2.76 miles

Passionate Gourmet

1.29 miles

Omar's Pueblo Viejo

1.30 miles

Carmel Diner

1.38 miles

Thai Golden

1.53 miles

Applebee's

1.57 miles

China Taste

1.58 miles

Dunkin'

1.60 miles

Gaetano Pizza & Cafe

1.70 miles

Eveready Diner

1.70 miles

La Famiglia Bar & Grill

2.38 miles

ShopRite

1.32 miles

Tops

1.64 miles

Marshalls

1.69 miles

DeCicco & Sons Brewster

1.79 miles

Kohl's

1.81 miles

Lakeview Shopping Center

4.09 miles

Acme

4.11 miles

Value Village

4.15 miles

Salinger's Orchard

5.16 miles

A&P Supermarket

6.51 miles

Community Pharmacy

1.72 miles

Putnam Hospital Center

3.69 miles

New York State Police Troop K SP Brewster

4.14 miles

Patterson Fire Department

6.14 miles

Croton Falls Volunteer Fire Department

6.35 miles

Mahopac Falls Fire Department

6.75 miles

Mahopac

7.14 miles

Somers Fire House

7.67 miles

New York State Police

8.08 miles

North Salem Town Police

8.09 miles

Listing Summary

  • Property Financials

    189 Fair St is currently listed for sale at $799,000 for a price per square foot of $193.88.

  • Property Details

    189 Fair St totals 4,121 square feet of Multi-Family space on a lot spanning 2.51 acres. The property was initially built in 2000.

    Based on its location, amenities, and finishes, the property is listed as class C.

  • Area Characteristics

    189 Fair St is located in the Carmel Hamlet neighborhood.

    In terms of ease of commuting, the area has a walk score of 3, indicating that it is car-dependent.

Contact Todd Albright
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.