• Property Lists
  • Listings
    • Commercial Real Estate
  • Comparables
  • Owners
  • Maps
  • Resources
    • Learning Center
    • Blog
Add a Listing Advertise
  1. Commercial Properties
  2. IN
  3. Gary

1164 Connecticut St

For Sale

1164 Connecticut Street, Gary, IN 46407

Situated just off Broadway in Gary, IN, the property is within walking distance to retail, grocery, and entertainment amenities and minutes from surrounding schools and nearby cities.The investment opportunity offers a clear value-add strategy through renovating the remaining unrenovated units, completing full gut rehabs of the two vacant units, and improving operations through modern leasing, marketing, and maintenance systems. The property consists of two adjacent buildings located at 1164 and 1170 Connecticut St. in Gary, Indiana, within walking distance to retail, grocery, and entertainment and just minutes from surrounding schools and nearby cities. Originally built in 1927 and updated over time, the buildings feature multiple entrances, ample street parking, and access to an adjacent vacant lot used for tenant parking. Unit interiors include hardwood floors, wood trim, updated kitchens in select units, and strong natural light throughout. Tenants separately pay cooking gas and electric through NIPSCO, while ownership covers heat, common area electric, and water, creating potential upside through future RUBs implementation. Additional upside exists through basement renovations to bring tenant storage and on-site laundry online. Most units have already received light renovations including updated finishes, flooring, cabinets, and appliances. Major capital improvements include complete tear-off roof replacements in 2021 and new boiler systems installed in 2022. Positioned just off Broadway, Gary's main north-south corridor, the asset stands to benefit from ongoing redevelopment and investment throughout the area.

Key features

  • Basement renovation opportunity for tenant storage and on-site laundry
  • Benefits from ongoing redevelopment and investment in the area
  • Clear value-add strategy through renovating remaining unrenovated units
  • Complete full gut rehabs of two vacant units
  • Complete tear-off roof replacements in 2021
  • Hardwood floors, wood trim, updated kitchens in select units
  • Improve operations through modern leasing, marketing, and maintenance systems
  • Most units already received light renovations
  • Multiple entrances and ample street parking
  • New boiler systems installed in 2022
  • Positioned just off Broadway, Gary's main north-south corridor
  • Potential upside through future RUBs implementation
  • Two adjacent buildings at 1164 and 1170 Connecticut St.
  • Within walking distance to retail, grocery, and entertainment

Building Details

  • For Sale $1,050,000
  • Property Type Multi-Family
  • Property Size 13,400 SF
  • Units 19
  • Lot Size 0.23 Acre
  • Additional Rent Price on request
  • Year Built 1927
  • Year Renovated 2025
  • Date Updated Aug 25, 2026
View Attachment
Want more info on this listing?

Reach out to the broker for more info on lease terms and amenities

False

Contacts

broker
Kyle Sissell

Kiser Group

Location

  • City Gary, IN
  • Neighborhood Midtown Gary
  • Zip Code 46407
  • Market Chicago
  • Map
  • Street
  • Walk score 57/100 Somewhat Walkable
  • Bike score 50/100 Bikeable
Powered by Walk Score ®

Points of Interest

Gary Metro Center

1.02 miles

East Chicago

7.60 miles

Citgo

0.20 miles

Save

0.68 miles

All Star

0.72 miles

Amoco

1.05 miles

Grant Gas & Mini Food Mart

1.14 miles

Clark

1.21 miles

Fuel Stop

1.31 miles

AmpUp

3.54 miles

ChargePoint

6.91 miles

Tesla Supercharger

8.42 miles

B Lot

1.15 miles

Medical Lot

1.18 miles

A Lot

1.21 miles

Seniority Lot

1.24 miles

1 BOP Lot

1.37 miles

Sinter Plant Lot

1.82 miles

Coke Plant Lot

1.89 miles

Village Mall parking

2.80 miles

84 HSM Parking Lot

3.14 miles

Andrean High School parking

5.53 miles

Car Wash

0.18 miles

Rio's Wash Wax & Detail

0.62 miles

Ace Car Care

1.26 miles

Auto Spa of NWI LLC

1.99 miles

Tsunami Express Car Wash

2.39 miles

Enterprise

3.01 miles

Superior Car Wash & Auto Detailing

3.38 miles

K&B Hand Car Wash & Detailing

4.32 miles

Blue Beacon

4.98 miles

Easy Clean Car Wash

6.84 miles

79th Street BBQ

0.13 miles

White Castle

0.13 miles

Church's Chicken

0.14 miles

Sharks Fish & Chicken

0.15 miles

Little Caesars

0.16 miles

Popeyes

0.18 miles

Gowdy's Seafood of GARY

0.25 miles

KFC

0.33 miles

Lo'Shell's Cajun And Creole Flavors

0.48 miles

Food Express Café

0.84 miles

Save More Foods

0.29 miles

K & M Food Mart

1.56 miles

Grocery Outlet

1.64 miles

Fresh County Market

1.85 miles

ALDI

2.42 miles

The Village Mall

2.83 miles

Save-A-Lot

4.85 miles

Strack & Van Til

5.27 miles

Ruler Foods

5.77 miles

Big Lots

7.27 miles

CVS Pharmacy

0.19 miles

Chube Medical Clinic

0.34 miles

Gary Fire Department Station #2

0.36 miles

Gary Fire Department Station #1

0.83 miles

Gary Fire Department Station #12

1.01 miles

Gary Police Department

1.05 miles

Community HealthNet Health Centers

1.14 miles

Gary Fire Department Station #4

1.20 miles

Northlake Campus Methodist Hospitals

1.36 miles

Gary Fire Department Station #3

1.51 miles

Listing Summary

  • What is the asking price at 1164 Connecticut St?

    1164 Connecticut St is currently listed for sale at Price on request.

  • What is the total size of 1164 Connecticut St?

    1164 Connecticut St has a total of 13,400 square feet.

  • What is the year built for 1164 Connecticut St?

    The year built for 1164 Connecticut St is 1927.

Contact Kyle Sissell
broker
Kyle Sissell

Kiser Group

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Nearby Listings

1412 Connecticut Street

1412 Connecticut Street

1412 Connecticut, Gary, IN
$350,000
Property
  • Multi-Family
  • 4,200 SF
6021-55 Canden Ave., 2378-2400 Dixie Dr. , 6021-6121 McCasland Ave

6021-55 Canden Ave., 2378-2400 Dixie Dr. , 6021-6121 McCasland Ave

6021-55 Canden Ave., 2378-2400 Dixie Dr. , 6021-6121 McCasland Ave, Portage, IN
$11,500,000
Property
  • Multi-Family
  • 96,200 SF
8940 White Oak Ave

8940 White Oak Ave

8940 White Oak Ave, Munster, IN
$1,095,000
Property
  • Multi-Family
  • 6,216 SF
1104 - 169th

1104 - 169th

1104 169th St, Hammond, IN
$695,000
Property
  • Multi-Family
  • 4,050 SF
11 E 157th St., Calumet City, IL 60409

11 E 157th St., Calumet City, IL 60409

11 157th Street, Calumet City, IL
$400,000
Property
  • Multi-Family
  • 5,000 SF

Popular Searches

  • Chicago Office Properties for Sale
  • Merrillville Office Properties for Sale
  • Evanston Office Properties for Sale
  • Chicago Commercial Real Estate
  • Joliet Commercial Real Estate
  • South Bend Commercial Real Estate
  • Naperville Commercial Real Estate
  • Merrillville Commercial Real Estate
  • Schaumburg Commercial Real Estate
  • Crown Point Commercial Real Estate
  • Gary Commercial Real Estate
  • Hammond Commercial Real Estate
  • Arlington Heights Commercial Real Estate
  • Blog
  • X
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • About
  • Our Services
  • Contact Us
  • Sitemaps
  • Privacy Policy
  • Your CA Privacy Rights
  • Terms Of Service
  • FAQ

Customer Service

  • (718)715-1758
  • Contact us
Copyright 2003-2026, PropertyShark.com