3500 Montgomery

For Sale

3500 Montgomery Rd, Cincinnati, OH 45207

Prominently positioned at the corner of Montgomery Road and Duck Creek Road in Cincinnati’s Evanston neighborhood, offering strong visibility and convenient access to the region’s primary transportation corridors. The property is located just minutes from I-71.Astonish Commercial Real Estate Services is pleased to present 3500 Montgomery Road, the former St. Mark's Church, a 47,534 +/- SF special purpose property offered via online auction on Crexi.com. Located in Cincinnati’s Evanston neighborhood near Xavier University, the property is situated on a prominent 2.363-acre corner site along Montgomery Road. The former church campus offers a substantial existing building footprint with distinctive institutional architecture and a highly visible corner location. Its size, configuration, and location near Xavier University create potential for continued institutional or community use, educational or nonprofit occupancy, adaptive reuse, or redevelopment. The property presents a unique opportunity to acquire a recognizable Cincinnati property with significant long-term repositioning potential.

Key features

  • 2.363 AC Corner Site
  • Bridge: 766 +/- SF
  • Co-broke available
  • Constructed in 1940
  • Expansive 47,534+/- SF Property
  • Former Historic Church
  • Providing convenient connectivity to Clifton, downtown Cincinnati, Hyde Park, Eastern Suburbs and Northern KY
  • Rectory: 13,949 +/- SF
  • Sanctuary: 32,819 +/- SF
  • Zoned SF-2

Building Details

  • For Sale Starting Bid: $150,000
  • Property Type Other - Special Purpose
  • Property Size 47,534 SF
  • Lot Size 2.36 Acre
  • Additional Rent Price on request
  • Year Built 1940
  • Date Updated Sep 30, 2026
View Attachment
Want more info on this listing?

Reach out to the broker for more info on lease terms and amenities

Contacts

Kristina Skurow

Astonish

Location

  • City Cincinnati, OH
  • Neighborhood Evanston
  • Zip Code 45207
  • Market Cincinnati
  • Walk score 73/100 Very Walkable
  • Transit score 52/100 Good Transit
  • Bike score 42/100 Somewhat Bikeable
Powered by Walk Score ®

Points of Interest

Findlay Market–Race

3.16 miles

Brewery District

3.19 miles

Hanke Exchange

3.21 miles

Findlay Market–Elm

3.25 miles

Liberty & Race

3.25 miles

Court & Main

3.27 miles

Liberty & Elm

3.31 miles

12th & Vine

3.34 miles

8th & Main

3.35 miles

Central Parkway

3.38 miles

UDF Fuel

0.27 miles

Top Up Mart Fuel

1.28 miles

Speedway

1.30 miles

BP

1.49 miles

Shell

1.54 miles

Kroger

2.09 miles

Daniels Street Fast Charger

2.32 miles

Clifton Court Garage Charging Station

2.57 miles

Tesla Supercharger

2.75 miles

FLO

3.18 miles

Cintas Center East Parking Area

0.58 miles

Lot 1

0.88 miles

Lot 2

0.92 miles

Cincinnati Police Department District 4

1.13 miles

Central Parking

1.52 miles

Northern Avenue Garage

1.53 miles

Visitor Parking

1.63 miles

CCHMC South Parking

1.66 miles

Shriners Garage

1.66 miles

UCMC Sabin Way Garage

1.71 miles

Zipcar

2.35 miles

Mike's Carwash

2.69 miles

Mister Bubbles Complete Care Detailing

2.91 miles

Soft Cloth Car Wash

3.06 miles

Enterprise

3.46 miles

Whitewater Express Car Wash

3.58 miles

Hertz

3.72 miles

Rainbow Car Wash

3.76 miles

BP

4.91 miles

Self Service Car Wash

5.52 miles

DELICIO Coal Fired Pizza

0.33 miles

Domino's

0.65 miles

O’Bryon’s Bar & Grill

0.82 miles

Ché

0.86 miles

Oriental Wok

0.89 miles

Suzie Wong's on Madison

0.93 miles

Cafe Mochiko

0.95 miles

Gordo’s Pub & Grill

1.15 miles

Chipotle

1.24 miles

Qdoba

1.24 miles

Whole Foods Market

1.29 miles

Kroger

1.39 miles

Kroger Hyde Park

2.22 miles

Freshmarket

2.26 miles

Kohl's

2.47 miles

Target

2.64 miles

Clifton Market

2.65 miles

Meijer

2.66 miles

ALDI

3.08 miles

Shoppes at Carew Tower

3.70 miles

Trihealth Rehabilitation Hospital

0.64 miles

Engine 23 Truck

0.95 miles

Number 9 Engine Company

1.10 miles

Cincinnati Police Department District 4

1.14 miles

Fire Station 32

1.21 miles

Fire Station 9

1.49 miles

CVS Pharmacy

1.51 miles

Mayfield Spine Surgery Center

1.51 miles

Fire Station 46

1.56 miles

Norwood Police Department

1.58 miles

Listing Summary

  • Property Financials

    3500 Montgomery Rd is currently listed for sale at Starting Bid: $150,000.

  • Property Details

    3500 Montgomery Rd totals 47,534 square feet of Mixed Use space on a lot spanning 2.36 acres. The property was initially built in 1940.

  • Area Characteristics

    3500 Montgomery Rd is located in the Evanston neighborhood.

    In terms of ease of commuting, the area has a walk score of 73, indicating that it is very walkable.

Contact Kristina Skurow
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.