| Primary address | 419 Mystic Way, Bay Shore |
| Zip code | 11706 |
| County | Suffolk |
| Municipality | Islip |
| Parcel ID | 417-2-35 |
View detailed information on past sales, title documents and property taxes, including the assessed market value, in their dedicated tabs.
| Sale date | 06/18/2012 |
| Sale price | $379,000 |
| Arm's length | Register |
| Current property tax | $10,138 |
| Building class | One Family Year-Round Residence (210) |
| Acreage | 0.14 |
| Zoning district | Register |
| School district | Bay Shore |
View more neighborhood information such as transportation, nearby schools and risk designations in the dedicated tab.
Property reports include comprehensive occupancy, improvement and development information (where available).
Create a free account to access valuable data points such as:
Assessed at $46,800, the tax amount paid for 419 Mystic Way, Bay Shore, NY 11706 is $14,315.
When was 419 Mystic Way, Bay Shore, NY 11706 last sold and what was the last sale price?419 Mystic Way, Bay Shore, NY 11706 was last sold in 06/18/2012 for $379,000.
View detailed property contacts like owners, building management, representatives from permits and tenants with a free account.
Create a free account to view the complete sales history for 419 Mystic Way, Bay Shore, including title documents, transfer conditions, mortgages and liens.
*Here are the three most recent sales for this property.
To view the complete history of deeds, mortgages, assignments of leases and rents, and more, sign up for free. Available data goes back to 1966.
R: Recorded date
D: Document date
Access detailed property tax data for 419 Mystic Way, Bay Shore, NY 11706. Tax information included: property tax, market value and assessed value, exemptions, abatements, and assessment history.
| Tax year | 2025-2026 |
| Base tax | $14,316 |
| Current property tax | $10,138 |
| Market value | $659,155 |
| Assessed value | $46,800 |
Here's the assessment & property tax history for 419 Mystic Way, Bay Shore, including the evolution of the total tax rate and corresponding property tax.
| Year | Market value | Assessment value | Total tax rate | Property tax | Year over year change |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2025-2026 | $659,155 | $46,800 | 30.589 | $14,316 | -10.84% |
| 2024-2025 | $771,831 | $54,800 | 29.299 | $16,056 | +4.40% |
| 2023-2024 | $752,747 | $54,800 | 28.063 | $15,379 | -0.15% |
| 2022-2023 | $661,836 | $54,800 | 28.104 | $15,401 | +0.31% |
| 2021-2022 | $590,518 | $54,800 | 28.016 | $15,353 | +2.87% |
The complete history of permits filed for 419 Mystic Way, Bay Shore, including new construction or demolition permits, plus any work pertaining to plumbing, heating and sprinkler systems is available with a free account. Available data goes back to 1990.
Create a free account to unlock extended information for 419 Mystic Way, Bay Shore, including whether it's located in FEMA flood zones, floodways or special flood hazard areas, as well as the Coastal barriers resources system area (COBRA).
| FEMA flood zone(s) | X (See more on map) |
Access the detailed traffic volume map for 419 Mystic Way, Bay Shore to see estimated average daily traffic on streets surrounding the property as well as the types of properties in its vicinity.
| View daily traffic map |
| Name | Rating | Type | Grade range | No of students | Distance to school (mi) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gardiner Manor School | 4 | Public | 3-5 | 702 | 0.28 |
| South Country School | 3 | Public | 3-5 | 469 | 0.66 |
| St Peters By The Sea Episcopal Day School | NR | Private | PK, K-8 | 176 | 1.04 |
| St Peters By The Sea Episcopal Day School | NR | Private | PK, K-8 | 176 | 1.04 |
| Bay Shore Christian School | NR | Private | PK, K-6 | 236 | 1.20 |
| Name | Rating | Type | Grade range | No of students | Distance to school (mi) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| St Peters By The Sea Episcopal Day School | NR | Private | PK, K-8 | 176 | 1.04 |
| Udall Road Middle School | 6 | Public | 6-8 | 445 | 1.52 |
| Our Lady Of Lourdes School | NR | Private | PK-8 | 209 | 1.55 |
| Beach Street Middle School | 6 | Public | 6-8 | 405 | 1.62 |
| Bridges Academy (The) | NR | Private | PK-8 | 211 | 1.81 |
| Name | Rating | Type | Grade range | No of students | Distance to school (mi) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bay Shore Senior High School | 5 | Public | 9-12 | 1,910 | 1.46 |
| West Islip Senior High School | 9 | Public | 9-12 | 1,262 | 1.82 |
| St John The Baptist Diocesan High School | NR | Private | 9-12 | 1,335 | 1.82 |
| North Babylon High School | 6 | Public | 9-12 | 1,506 | 2.63 |
| Islip High School | 9 | Public | 9-12 | 892 | 2.89 |
Data provided by GreatSchools.org © 2025. All rights reserved.
Here are the neighbors for 419 Mystic Way, Bay Shore.
| Address | Square feet | Purchase date | Purchase price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 25 W Perkal St, Bay Shore | 12/05/2000 | $86,500 | |
| 46 Belford Ave, Bay Shore | 07/19/2016 | $221,000 | |
| 129 Connecticut Ave, Bay Shore | 12/08/2000 | $163,000 | |
| 23 Pineville Rd, Central Islip | 04/19/2006 | $257,000 | |
| 43 Ash St, Central Islip | 11/15/2023 | ||
| 196 Powell Ave, Central Islip | 07/02/2022 | ||
| 7 Juniper St, Islip | 06/16/2014 | ||
| 719 Montauk Hwy, Oakdale | 05/14/2008 | $361,000 | |
| 160 Stahley St, Brentwood | 1,138 | 10/29/2018 | |
| 240 Branch Ave, Central Islip | 01/03/2000 | ||
| 207 Timberline Dr, Brentwood | 09/14/2007 | ||
| 890 Lincoln Ave, Bohemia | 12,648 | 12/11/2000 | $1,000,000 |
| 127 Blake Ave, Bohemia | 05/02/2025 | $940,000 | |
| 1425 Madison Ave, West Islip | 03/24/2001 | ||
| 78 Opal St, Holbrook | 12/12/2000 | $235,000 | |
| 479 Nostrand Ave, Central Islip | 2,028 | 11/30/2020 | |
| 244 Foster Ave, Sayville | 05/13/2025 | $1,600,000 | |
| 59 Columbus Ave, Central Islip | 11/16/2000 | ||
| 200 Timberline Dr, Brentwood | 10/04/2002 | ||
| 448 Freeman Ave, Brentwood | 1,064 | 07/10/2017 | $325,000 |