New York City  »  10310  »  Cary Ave  »  538 Cary Ave

538 Cary Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10310 Property Information

538 Cary Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10310 Property Information

  • General
  • Owner
  • Documents
  • Tax
  • Permits
  • Neighborhood
Unlock this property report with a free account.

Access up-to-date information from property owner names to sales history, tax info, title documents, mortgages, development, maps, permits and more.
Sign Up Now
Research 100M+ property records powered by:
  • 2000+ governmental and public data sources
  • 80 dedicated analysts and researchers
  • 20+ years of real estate experience
Learn More

Photo & Map Show Hide

538 Cary Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10310
static Mapbox map

Address

Primary address 538 Cary Avenue
Neighborhood West Brighton
Zip code 10310
Borough Staten island
Block & lot 00218-0031

Sales & Tax Overview for 538 Cary Avenue, Staten Island

View detailed information on past sales, title documents and property taxes, including the assessed market value, in their dedicated tabs.

Tax class
Estimated property tax $4,749

Lot & Building Information for 538 Cary Avenue, Staten Island

Lot sqft 2,400
Lot dimensions 24 ft x 100 ft
Building class Two Family Frame (B2)
Building sqft 2,392
Building dimensions 20 ft x 45 ft
Buildings on lot 1
Stories 2
Structure type Old style
Building material Frame
Exterior wall Aluminum/vinyl
Basement type Full
Year built 1899
Frontage(s) Cary Avenue (wide)
Unlock this property report with a free account.

Access up-to-date information from property owner names to sales history, tax info, title documents, mortgages, development, maps, permits and more.
Sign Up Now

Zoning & Use for 538 Cary Avenue, Staten Island

Zoning
Residential units (DOF) 2
Residential sqft

Area Overview

Walk Score
63 /100. Somewhat Walkable
Transit Score
64 /100. Good Transit
Bike Score
57 /100. Bikeable

School district 31
Community district 1
Closest police station 0.48 Miles
Closest fire station 0.17 Miles

View more neighborhood information such as transportation, nearby schools and risk designations in the dedicated tab.

Other Property Data for 538 Cary Avenue, Staten Island

New York property reports include comprehensive occupancy, development and violation information. Create a free account to access valuable data points such as:

Floor area ratio (FAR) for 538 Cary Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10310, including commercial and residential FAR, FAR as built and usable floor area.
Development maps such as planimetric, zoning, urban landscape, and HPD alternative enforcement program maps.
Violations for 538 Cary Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10310, including DOB violations, ECB violations, HPD violations and 311 complaints.

About 538 Cary Avenue, Staten Island

What is the year built & the total sq. ft. for 538 Cary Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10310?

538 Cary Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10310 was built in 1899 and has a total of 2,392 square feet.

What is the assessed value of 538 Cary Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10310 and the property tax paid?

Assessed at $47,760, the tax amount paid for 538 Cary Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10310 is $4,749. For the next year, the tax amount for 538 Cary Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10310 is estimated at $4,749.

How many residential units does this building have?

This building has 2 residential unit(s).

Ownership Information for 538 Cary Avenue, Staten Island

View property contacts like owners, building management, representatives from permits and tenants with a free account. For LLC-owned properties, access manually researched real owners and phone numbers.

Property owner name for 538 Cary Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10310
Find out who owns 538 Cary Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10310.
Sign Up
Building contacts for 538 Cary Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10310
Building management:
Representatives (from permits):
Tenants:
Real Estate Reports:
$4.6M Hudson Yards Maintains Top Spot, Luxury Sales in Malba Set $2.5M Price Record for Queens
Eliza Theiss, Apr 23, 2026 $4.6M Hudson Yards Maintains Top Spot, Luxury Sales in Malba Set $2.5M Price Record for Queens
Despite prices declining, Hudson Yards remained the most expensive NYC neighborhood, but TriBeCa’s growth closed the gap to under $400,000, while Malba set a new historic price record for Queens at $2.5 million, securing the highest ranking ever for the borough at #5.
Cheaper in the City? Nearly 100 Communities in Suburban NYC Surpass $1M
Eliza Theiss, Mar 19, 2026 Cheaper in the City? Nearly 100 Communities in Suburban NYC Surpass $1M
New Yorkers planning a move to the suburbs increasingly find their options limited, after suburban home values shot up twice as fast as NYC medians over the last decade. While larger homes and better prices were long the norm outside the five boroughs, today, many NYC buyers find their option restricted to a handful of suburban markets.
Research 100M+ property records powered by:
  • 2000+ governmental and public data sources
  • 80 dedicated analysts and researchers
  • 20+ years of real estate experience
Learn More

Past Sales & Property History for 538 Cary Avenue, Staten Island

Create a free account to view the complete sales history for 538 Cary Avenue, Staten Island, including title documents, transfer conditions, mortgages, liens, and pre-foreclosures.

No recorded sales for this property.

Title Documents for 538 Cary Avenue, Staten Island

Data not available for this property.

Property Taxes for 538 Cary Avenue, Staten Island

Access detailed property tax data for 538 Cary Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10310. Tax information included: property tax, market value and assessed value, exemptions, abatements, and assessment history.

Tax year: 2025-2026
Property tax: $4,749
Estimated property tax: $4,749
Tax assessor's market value: $796,000
Assessed value: $47,760

More about New York City Property Taxes

Assessment History for 538 Cary Avenue, Staten Island

Here's the assessment & property tax history for 538 Cary Avenue, Staten Island, including the evolution of the total tax rate and corresponding property tax.

Year Market value Assessed value Taxable Tax rate % Base tax Property tax Year over year change
2025/26 $796,000 $47,760 $23,933 19.843% $4,749 $4,749 -0.45%
2024/25 $713,000 $42,780 $23,752 20.085% $4,771 $4,771 +6.00%
2023/24 $751,000 $45,060 $22,408 20.085% $4,501 $4,501 +4.83%
2022/23 $611,000 $36,660 $21,140 20.309% $4,293 $4,293 +7.85%
2021/22 $625,000 $37,500 $19,944 19.963% $3,981 $3,981 -5.15%
Show More

Permits for 538 Cary Avenue, Staten Island

The complete history of permits filed for 538 Cary Avenue, Staten Island, including new construction or demolition permits, plus any work pertaining to plumbing, heating and sprinkler systems is available with a free account. Available data goes back to 1990.

No recorded permits for this property.

West Brighton Residential Market Stats

Access a detailed real estate market overview of West Brighton so you can assess current trends, home values, types of properties sold and transaction volume.
View the median home sale price in West Brighton and compare it to other neighborhoods in Staten Island.

Median Sale Price
$746,499
16.2% YoY
Median Price/Sqft
$451
-5.1% YoY
Staten Island Median Sale Price
$732,500
4.7% YoY

Check out recently sold homes in Staten Island and see how their prices compare.

Risk

FEMA flood zone(s): X (See more on map)

Transportation

Distance to Subway
Closest station Bay St & Cross St at NE Corner
Station lines SIR
Distance (miles) 2.376
View subway map
Bus Routes
Name Cary Av/Elizabeth St
Line S44
Distance (miles) 0.028

Schools

Nearest elementary schools

Name Rating Att. zoned Type Grade range No of students Distance to school (mi)
P.S. 19 The Curtis School 4 Yes Public PK, K-5 454 0.39
P.S. 19 The Curtis School 4 Yes Public PK, K-5 454 0.39
Our Lady Of Mt Carmel-St Benedicta School NR No Private PK-8 155 0.29
Our Lady Of Mt Carmel-St Benedicta School NR No Private PK-8 155 0.29
Sacred Heart School NR No Private PK-8 275 0.34
Show More

Nearest middle schools

Name Rating Att. zoned Type Grade range No of students Distance to school (mi)
Is 27 Anning S Prall 5 Yes Public 6-8 952 0.28
Our Lady Of Mt Carmel-St Benedicta School NR No Private PK-8 155 0.29
Sacred Heart School NR No Private PK-8 275 0.34
Blessed Sacrament School NR No Private PK, K-8 469 0.42
Is 61 William A Morris 4 No Public 6-8 932 1.18
Show More

Nearest high schools

Name Rating Att. zoned Type Grade range No of students Distance to school (mi)
Susan E Wagner High School 5 Yes Public 9-12 2,916 2.41
Yeshiva Tifereth Torah NR No Private 9-12 0 0.13
Port Richmond High School 3 No Public 9-12 1,693 1.19
St Peters Boys High School NR No Private 9-12 466 1.23
Notre Dame Academy High School NR No Private 9-12 438 1.66
Show More

Data provided by GreatSchools.org © 2025. All rights reserved.

Neighbors for 538 Cary Avenue, Staten Island

Here are the neighbors for 538 Cary Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10310.

Address Square feet Purchase date Purchase price
526 Cary Ave, Staten Island 1,911 02/29/2008 $288,888
114 Caroline St, Staten Island 1,500
544 Cary Ave, Staten Island 1,480
102 Caroline St, Staten Island 2,297 10/24/2023 $565,000
542 Cary Ave, Staten Island 1,524 06/06/2014 $255,000
121 Elizabeth St, Staten Island 2,062
109 Elizabeth St, Staten Island 2,841
528 Cary Ave, Staten Island 1,640
98 Caroline St, Staten Island 2,464 06/06/2008 $365,000
95 Elizabeth St, Staten Island 1,407 11/09/2018 $410,000
119 Elizabeth St, Staten Island 2,900
530 Cary Ave, Staten Island 1,640
90 Caroline St, Staten Island 3,060
96 Caroline St, Staten Island 2,168
110 Caroline St, Staten Island 3,465 03/21/2016
91 Elizabeth St, Staten Island 1,632 10/15/2021
103 Elizabeth St, Staten Island 2,340
536 Cary Ave, Staten Island 1,856
93 Elizabeth St, Staten Island 1,925 09/12/2018 $435,690
99 Elizabeth St, Staten Island 2,135
Show More
Not sure if we cover all the data-points you need? View sample full report View sample full report