5 Tuthill Drive, Shelter Island, NY 11964 Property Information
5 Tuthill Drive, Shelter Island, NY 11964 Property Information
- General
- Owner
- Documents
- Tax
- Permits
- Neighborhood
Address
| Primary address | 5 Tuthill Drive, Shelter Island |
| Zip code | 11964 |
| County | Suffolk |
| Municipality | Shelter Island |
| Parcel ID | 11-1-2 |
Sales & Tax Overview for 5 Tuthill Drive, Shelter Island
View detailed information on past sales, title documents and property taxes, including the assessed market value, in their dedicated tabs.
| Sale date | 10/22/2021 |
| Sale price | $920,000 |
| Arm's length | Register |
| Current property tax | $3,388 |
Lot & Building Information for 5 Tuthill Drive, Shelter Island
| Building class | Residential Vacant Land (311) |
| Acreage | 1.6 |
| Frontage | 235 |
Zoning, Use & Area Overview
| Zoning district | Register |
| School district | Shelter Island |
View more neighborhood information such as transportation, nearby schools and risk designations in the dedicated tab.
Other Property Data for 5 Tuthill Drive, Shelter Island
Property reports include comprehensive occupancy, improvement and development information (where available).
Create a free account to access valuable data points such as:
- • Improvements for 5 Tuthill Drive, Shelter Island , including their type, square footage, grade and when they were built.
- • Development maps such as planimetric, zoning, land use and urban landscape maps (building age and stories).
Sign up
About 5 Tuthill Drive, Shelter Island
The current market value is $775,900.
Ownership Information
View detailed property contacts like owners, building management, representatives from permits and tenants with a free account.
Past Sales & Property History for 5 Tuthill Drive, Shelter Island
Create a free account to view the complete sales history for 5 Tuthill Drive, Shelter Island, including title documents, transfer conditions, mortgages and liens.
Sign up
Title Documents for 5 Tuthill Drive, Shelter Island
To view the complete history of deeds, mortgages, assignments of leases and rents, and more, sign up for free. Available data goes back to 1966.
Sign up
R: Recorded date
D: Document date
Property Taxes for 5 Tuthill Drive, Shelter Island
Access detailed property tax data for 5 Tuthill Drive, Shelter Island, NY 11964. Tax information included: property tax, market value and assessed value, exemptions, abatements, and assessment history.
| Tax year | 2025-2026 |
| Base tax | $3,245 |
| Current property tax | $3,388 |
| Market value | $775,900 |
| Assessed value | $775,900 |
Assessment History for 5 Tuthill Drive, Shelter Island
Here's the assessment & property tax history for 5 Tuthill Drive, Shelter Island, including the evolution of the total tax rate and corresponding property tax.
| Year | Market value | Assessment value | Total tax rate | Property tax | Year over year change |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2024-2025 | $785,735 | $534,300 | 6.6835 | $3,571 | +5.30% |
| 2023-2024 | $731,918 | $534,300 | 6.3474 | $3,391 | +4.08% |
| 2022-2023 | $600,337 | $534,300 | 6.0985 | $3,258 | +1.28% |
| 2021-2022 | $534,300 | $534,300 | 6.0213 | $3,217 | +1.36% |
| 2020-2021 | $534,300 | $534,300 | 5.9407 | $3,174 | +12.36% |
Permits for 5 Tuthill Drive, Shelter Island
The complete history of permits filed for 5 Tuthill Drive, Shelter Island, including new construction or demolition permits, plus any work pertaining to plumbing, heating and sprinkler systems is available with a free account. Available data goes back to 1990.
Data not available for this property.
Risk
Create a free account to unlock extended information for 5 Tuthill Drive, Shelter Island, including whether it's located in FEMA flood zones, floodways or special flood hazard areas, as well as the Coastal barriers resources system area (COBRA).
| FEMA flood zone(s) | X (See more on map) |
Transportation
Access the detailed traffic volume map for 5 Tuthill Drive, Shelter Island to see estimated average daily traffic on streets surrounding the property as well as the types of properties in its vicinity.
| View daily traffic map |
Schools
Nearest elementary schools
| Name | Rating | Type | Grade range | No of students | Distance to school (mi) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shelter Island School | 5 | Public | PK, K-12 | 174 | 2.50 |
| Shelter Island School | 5 | Public | PK, K-12 | 174 | 2.50 |
| Greenport Elementary School | 3 | Public | PK, K-6 | 339 | 4.37 |
| Greenport Elementary School | 3 | Public | PK, K-6 | 339 | 4.37 |
| Oysterponds Elementary School | NR | Public | PK, K-6 | 80 | 4.70 |
Nearest middle schools
| Name | Rating | Type | Grade range | No of students | Distance to school (mi) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shelter Island School | 5 | Public | PK, K-12 | 174 | 2.50 |
| Greenport High School | 5 | Public | 7-12 | 356 | 4.37 |
| Pierson Middle High School | 5 | Public | 6-12 | 525 | 5.73 |
| Southold Junior Senior High School | 5 | Public | 7-12 | 380 | 7.38 |
| Ross School | NR | Private | PK-12 | 318 | 7.91 |
Nearest high schools
| Name | Rating | Type | Grade range | No of students | Distance to school (mi) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shelter Island School | 5 | Public | PK, K-12 | 174 | 2.50 |
| Greenport High School | 5 | Public | 7-12 | 356 | 4.37 |
| Pierson Middle High School | 5 | Public | 6-12 | 525 | 5.73 |
| Southold Junior Senior High School | 5 | Public | 7-12 | 380 | 7.38 |
| Ross School | NR | Private | PK-12 | 318 | 7.91 |
Data provided by GreatSchools.org © 2025. All rights reserved.
Neighbors for 5 Tuthill Drive, Shelter Island
Here are the neighbors for 5 Tuthill Drive, Shelter Island.
| Address | Square feet | Purchase date | Purchase price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 7 Tuthill Dr, Shelter Island | 1,802 | 04/27/2013 | $450,000 |
| 17 Tuthill Dr, Shelter Island | 01/28/2022 | $650,000 | |
| 4 Tuthill Dr, Shelter Island | 2,244 | 07/23/2020 | $1,775,000 |
| 16 Tuthill Dr, Shelter Island | 3,468 | 07/22/2011 | $1 |
| 124 Ram Island Dr, Shelter Island | 07/23/1999 | $235,000 | |
| 26 S Ram Island Dr, Shelter Island | 2,880 | ||
| 19 Tuthill Dr, Shelter Island | 2,604 | 06/29/2020 | $1 |
| 12 Tuthill Dr, Shelter Island | 1,689 | ||
| 9 Tuthill Dr, Shelter Island | 2,012 | ||
| 28 S Ram Island Dr, Shelter Island | 2,645 | 02/24/2014 | $435,000 |
| 14 Tuthill Dr, Shelter Island | |||
| 10 Tuthill Dr, Shelter Island | 4,628 | 08/30/1995 | $510,000 |
| 1 Tuthill Dr, Shelter Island | 07/23/2020 | $150,000 | |
| 122 Ram Island Dr, Shelter Island | |||
| 8 Tuthill Dr, Shelter Island | 1,545 | 04/27/2013 | $200,000 |
| 24 S Ram Island Dr, Shelter Island | 1,448 | ||
| 6 Tuthill Dr, Shelter Island | 2,104 | 10/21/2005 | $1 |
| 2 A Tuthill Dr, Shelter Island | 3,210 |