Suffolk County  »  11964  »  Pennys Path  »  4 Pennys Path

4 Pennys Path, Shelter Island, NY 11964 Property Information

4 Pennys Path, Shelter Island, NY 11964 Property Information

  • General
  • Owner
  • Documents
  • Tax
  • Permits
  • Neighborhood
Unlock this property report with a free account.

Access up-to-date information from property owner names to sales history, tax info, title documents, mortgages, development, maps, permits and more.
Sign Up Now
Research 100M+ property records powered by:
  • 2000+ governmental and public data sources
  • 80 dedicated analysts and researchers
  • 20+ years of real estate experience
Learn More

Photo & Map Show Hide

4 Pennys Path, Shelter Island, NY 11964
static Mapbox map

Address

Primary address 4 Pennys Path, Shelter Island
Zip code 11964
County Suffolk
Municipality Shelter Island
Parcel ID 17-2-45

Sales & Tax Overview for 4 Pennys Path, Shelter Island

View detailed information on past sales, title documents and property taxes, including the assessed market value, in their dedicated tabs.

Sale date 11/15/2024
Sale price $1
Arm's length
Current property tax $5,829

Lot & Building Information for 4 Pennys Path, Shelter Island

Building sqft 1,249
Building class One Family Year-Round Residence (210)
Acreage 0.62
Frontage 138
Year built 1963
Year last altered 2017
Stories 1
Rooms 6
Bedrooms 4
Bathrooms 3
Unlock this property report with a free account.

Access up-to-date information from property owner names to sales history, tax info, title documents, mortgages, development, maps, permits and more.
Sign Up Now

Zoning, Use & Area Overview

Walk Score
0 /100. Car-Dependent
Transit Score
0 /100. Minimal Transit
Bike Score
25 /100. Somewhat Bikeable

Zoning district
School district Shelter Island

View more neighborhood information such as transportation, nearby schools and risk designations in the dedicated tab.

Other Property Data for 4 Pennys Path, Shelter Island

Property reports include comprehensive occupancy, improvement and development information (where available).
Create a free account to access valuable data points such as:

  • • Improvements for 4 Pennys Path, Shelter Island , including their type, square footage, grade and when they were built.
  • • Development maps such as planimetric, zoning, land use and urban landscape maps (building age and stories).
Unlock all property data with a free account.
Sign up

About 4 Pennys Path, Shelter Island

What is the year built & the total sq. ft. for 4 Pennys Path, Shelter Island, NY 11964?

4 Pennys Path, Shelter Island, NY 11964 was built in 1963 and has a total of 1,249 square feet.

What is the assessed value of 4 Pennys Path, Shelter Island, NY 11964 and the property tax paid?

Assessed at $1,335,000, the tax amount paid for 4 Pennys Path, Shelter Island, NY 11964 is $5,582.

When was 4 Pennys Path, Shelter Island, NY 11964 last sold and what was the last sale price?

4 Pennys Path, Shelter Island, NY 11964 was last sold in 11/15/2024 for $1.

Ownership Information

View detailed property contacts like owners, building management, representatives from permits and tenants with a free account.

Real Estate Reports:
How to Contact Property Owners: Cold Calling Scripts, Email Templates & Outreach Tips 
Laura Pop-Badiu, Jul 29, 2026 How to Contact Property Owners: Cold Calling Scripts, Email Templates & Outreach Tips 
When it comes to efficiently contacting property owners, the challenge is twofold: First, you need to identify the right owner. Then, you need to reach that owner through the appropriate channel with the right message. Enhanced by effective follow-up tips and tactics, this guide is particularly useful for investors, agents and other real estate professionals who need an effective outreach process.
Brooklyn Emerges as NYC’s Coworking Growth Engine, Manhattan Rents Cross $100 in the Plaza District 
Lucian Alixandrescu, Jul 28, 2026 Brooklyn Emerges as NYC’s Coworking Growth Engine, Manhattan Rents Cross $100 in the Plaza District 
New York City’s office market continued to lead the U.S. in Q2, but internal shifts were most visible in the flex office market. Brooklyn’s coworking inventory grew 6.2% Q-o-Q even as Manhattan’s supply retreated. At the same time, Brooklyn’s asking rents for traditional office leases climbed more than twice as fast as the national average.
Prices Rise in 32 of NYC’s Leading Neighborhoods as City and Manhattan Hit Record Highs
Eliza Theiss, Jul 22, 2026 Prices Rise in 32 of NYC’s Leading Neighborhoods as City and Manhattan Hit Record Highs
Q2 2026 saw NYC and Manhattan reach historic highs, with Brooklyn and Queens marking close to new records as well. Meanwhile, Hudson Yards remained at the top, Central Midtown posted its highest price ever and Carroll Gardens marked its third consecutive quarter over $2 million
Research 100M+ property records powered by:
  • 2000+ governmental and public data sources
  • 80 dedicated analysts and researchers
  • 20+ years of real estate experience
Learn More

Past Sales & Property History for 4 Pennys Path, Shelter Island

Create a free account to view the complete sales history for 4 Pennys Path, Shelter Island, including title documents, transfer conditions, mortgages and liens.

Purchase date Purchase price Buyer name Seller name
11/15/2024 $1
02/10/2004 $440,000
03/26/2002 $1
       
       
Access the complete sales history for 4 Pennys Path, Shelter Island with a free account.
Sign up

*Here are the three most recent sales for this property.


More about Suffolk County Property Records

Title Documents for 4 Pennys Path, Shelter Island

To view the complete history of deeds, mortgages, assignments of leases and rents, and more, sign up for free. Available data goes back to 1966.

Date Type Amount Party 1 Party 2 Doc image
12/20/2024 - R
11/15/2024 - D		 Deed
03/15/2004 - R
02/10/2004 - D		 Deed
04/01/2002 - R
03/26/2002 - D		 Deed
08/12/1999 - R
07/29/1999 - D		 Deed
           
Show More
Unlock daily updated title documents, including buyer and seller information (when available).
Sign up

R: Recorded date
D: Document date

Property Taxes for 4 Pennys Path, Shelter Island

Access detailed property tax data for 4 Pennys Path, Shelter Island, NY 11964. Tax information included: property tax, market value and assessed value, exemptions, abatements, and assessment history.

Tax year 2025-2026
Base tax $5,583
Current property tax $5,829
Market value $1,335,000
Assessed value $1,335,000

More about Suffolk County Property Taxes

Assessment History for 4 Pennys Path, Shelter Island

Here's the assessment & property tax history for 4 Pennys Path, Shelter Island, including the evolution of the total tax rate and corresponding property tax.

Year Market value Assessment value Total tax rate Property tax Year over year change
2025-2026 $1,335,000 $1,335,000 4.1819 $5,583 +8.48%
2024-2025 $1,132,353 $770,000 6.6835 $5,146 +5.30%
2023-2024 $1,054,794 $770,000 6.3474 $4,887 +4.08%
2022-2023 $865,169 $770,000 6.0985 $4,696 +1.28%
2021-2022 $770,000 $770,000 6.0213 $4,636 +2.15%
Show More

Permits for 4 Pennys Path, Shelter Island

The complete history of permits filed for 4 Pennys Path, Shelter Island, including new construction or demolition permits, plus any work pertaining to plumbing, heating and sprinkler systems is available with a free account. Available data goes back to 1990.

Data not available for this property.

Risk

Create a free account to unlock extended information for 4 Pennys Path, Shelter Island, including whether it's located in FEMA flood zones, floodways or special flood hazard areas, as well as the Coastal barriers resources system area (COBRA).

FEMA flood zone(s) X (See more on map)

Transportation

Access the detailed traffic volume map for 4 Pennys Path, Shelter Island to see estimated average daily traffic on streets surrounding the property as well as the types of properties in its vicinity.

View daily traffic map

Schools

Nearest elementary schools

Name Rating Type Grade range No of students Distance (miles)
Shelter Island School 5 Public PK, K-12 174 1.59
Shelter Island School 5 Public PK, K-12 174 1.59
Greenport Elementary School 3 Public PK, K-6 339 3.02
Greenport Elementary School 3 Public PK, K-6 339 3.02
Southold Elementary School 7 Public K-6 317 3.45
Show More

Nearest middle schools

Name Rating Type Grade range No of students Distance (miles)
Shelter Island School 5 Public PK, K-12 174 1.59
Greenport High School 5 Public 7-12 356 3.02
Southold Junior Senior High School 5 Public 7-12 380 3.45
Pierson Middle High School 5 Public 6-12 525 5.97
The Hayground School NR Private PK-8 77 8.44
Show More

Nearest high schools

Name Rating Type Grade range No of students Distance (miles)
Shelter Island School 5 Public PK, K-12 174 1.59
Greenport High School 5 Public 7-12 356 3.02
Southold Junior Senior High School 5 Public 7-12 380 3.45
Pierson Middle High School 5 Public 6-12 525 5.97
Ross School NR Private PK-12 312 8.93
Show More

Data provided by GreatSchools.org © 2025. All rights reserved.

Neighbors for 4 Pennys Path, Shelter Island

Here are the neighbors for 4 Pennys Path, Shelter Island.

Address Square feet Purchase date Purchase price
6 Ole Buck Run, Shelter Island 1,802 04/25/2025 $1,320,000
8 Ole Buck Run, Shelter Island 1,330 04/25/2025 $1,320,000
17 Worthy Way, Shelter Island 2,116 07/03/2019 $755,000
2 Pennys Path, Shelter Island 2,579
7 Rebel Rd, Shelter Island 1,427 03/23/2006 $775,000
4 Ole Buck Run, Shelter Island Heights 1,810 07/04/2015 $1
2 Rebel Rd, Shelter Island 1,596 10/19/2020 $985,000
115 W Neck Rd, Shelter Island 2,317 12/28/2012 $1
6 Pennys Path, Shelter Island Heights 2,500 02/08/2000 $55,000
16 Pennys Path, Shelter Island 1,194 02/21/2024 $300,000
121 W Neck Rd, Shelter Island 07/11/2001 $25,000
119 W Neck Rd, Shelter Island
10 Pennys Path, Shelter Island 2,270 08/17/2023 $1,300,000
12 Pennys Path, Shelter Island 2,445 06/11/2014 $202,000
8 Pennys Path, Shelter Island 12/13/2024 $525,000
14 Worthy Way, Shelter Island 2,306 04/10/2013 $1
14 Pennys Path, Shelter Island
18 Worthy Way, Shelter Island 2,115 08/31/2000 $345,000
117 W Neck Rd, Shelter Island
113 W Neck Rd, Shelter Island 1,120 09/27/2013 $1,200,000
Show More

Nearby ZIP Codes for 4 Pennys Path, Shelter Island

Not sure if we cover all the data-points you need? View sample full report View sample full report