Suffolk County  »  11964  »  Worthy Way  »  5 Worthy Way

5 Worthy Way, Shelter Island, NY 11964 - Property report

Also known as: 5 Worthy Way

Property image for 5 Worthy Way, Shelter Island, NY 11964
static Mapbox map

Property type

One Family Year-Round Residence (210)

Year built

1977

Acreage

0.5

Sale price

$280,000

General information

Unlock this property report with a free account

Access up-to-date information from property owner names to sales history, deeds, tax info, mortgages, development data, planimetric maps and more.

Address
Primary address
5 Worthy Way
ZIP code
11964
County
Suffolk
Village (SWIS code)
473289
Parcel ID
17-2-39

Owner

Find out who owns 5 Worthy Way, Shelter Island, NY 11964. Uncover corporate and individual owners with a free account.

Sales
Sale date
05/07/2020
Sale price
$280,000
Arm's length
Tax
Tax year
2025-2026
Current property tax
$4,637
Zoning & Use
Zoning
Residential A (A)
Building
Property type
One Family Year-Round Residence (210)
Building sq. ft.
1,281
Buildings on lot
1
Stories
1
Year built
1977
AC
Yes
Rooms
6
Bedrooms
3
Bathrooms
1
Half bathrooms
1
Kitchens
1
Exterior wall
Wood
Building style
Ranch
Basement
Full
Fireplaces
1
Heating type
Hot water/steam
Heating fuel
Oil
Lot
Acreage
0.5
Road type
Improved
Site desirability
Typical

Area overview

Walk score
0 /100.  Car-Dependent
Transit score
0 /100.  Minimal Transit
Bike score
25 /100.  Somewhat Bikeable
School district
473201
Neighborhood type
Suburban
Neighborhood rating
Average

View more such as transportation, nearby schools and risk designations.

Ownership

Ownership information for 5 Worthy Way, Shelter Island, NY

Property owner name
Registered owner
Source
Deed
Owner contact information
Phone number
Owner address
Documents

Sales history for 5 Worthy Way, Shelter Island, NY 11964

Sale date Sale price Buyer name Seller name
05/07/2020 $280,000 XXXXX XXXXXXX X; XXXX XXXXXXXXXX X XXXXXXX XXXXXXX X
12/10/2015 $1 XXXXX XXXXXXX; XXXXXXX XXXXXXX X; XXXX XXXXXXXXXX X XXXX XXXXXXX XXXX
04/04/2008 $600,000 XXXX XXXXXXX XXXX XXXXXXXX XXXXXXXX; XXXXX XXXXXXX

*Most recent sales on record for this property.

More about Suffolk County property records.

Title documents

Date Type Amount Party 1 Party 2
04/27/2021 - R
05/07/2020 - D		 Deed
(Bargain and sale)		 XXXXXXX XXXXXXX X XXXXX XXXXXXX X
12/16/2015 - R
12/10/2015 - D		 Deed
(Executor)		 XXXX XXXXXXX XXXX XXXXX XXXXXXX
04/11/2008 - R
04/04/2008 - D		 Deed
(Bargain & sale deed)		 XXXXXXXX XXXXXXXX XXXX XXXXXXX XXXX
07/18/2003 - R
06/19/2003 - D		 Deed XXXXXXXXXXX XXXXX X XXXXXXX XXXXX
04/04/2003 - R
03/27/2003 - D		 Deed XXXX XXXXXXX XXXXX/XXXXX XXXX XXXXXXXXXXX XXXXX X
11/13/1995 - R
10/31/1995 - D		 Deed XXXXXX XXXXXX X XXXX XXXXXXX XXXXX/XXXXX XXX

*Most recent recorded documents on file for this property.

R: Recorded date
D: Document date

Tax

Property taxes for 5 Worthy Way, Shelter Island, NY

Property tax data includes tax amount, market value and assessed value, exemptions, abatements and assessment history.

Current property tax
Tax year
2025-2026
Current property tax
$4,637
Base tax
$4,441
Recent tax assessments
Market value
$1,062,000
Assessed value
$1,062,000

More about Suffolk County property taxes

Assessment history

See the assessment and property tax history, including the evolution of the total tax rate and corresponding property tax amount.

Tax year Market value Assessed value Tax rate Property tax Y-o-Y change
2025-2026 $1,062,000 $1,062,000 4.1819 $4,441 +15.57%
2024-2025 $845,589 $575,000 6.6835 $3,843 +5.30%
2023-2024 $787,671 $575,000 6.3474 $3,650 +4.08%
2022-2023 $646,067 $575,000 6.0985 $3,507 +1.28%
2021-2022 $575,000 $575,000 6.0213 $3,462 +3.89%
2020-2021 $561,000 $561,000 5.9407 $3,333 +12.97%
2019-2020 $558,000 $558,000 5.287 $2,950 -6.25%
2018-2019 $555,000 $555,000 5.67 $3,147 +1.96%
2017-2018 $541,000 $541,000 5.7049 $3,086 +0.69%
2016-2017 $525,000 $525,000 5.8385 $3,065 +3.67%
Permits

Permit information for 5 Worthy Way, Shelter Island, NY

No recently recorded permits for this property.

Neighborhood

Risk

Create a free account to unlock expanded risk information, such as crime incidents in the area, tsunami and landslides risks, or its location relative to FEMA flood zones and the Coastal Barriers Resources System Area (COBRA).

FEMA flood zones

FEMA flood zones
X

Transportation

Daily traffic map
View daily traffic map

Access the detailed traffic volume map for 5 Worthy Way, Shelter Island, NY 11964 to see estimated average daily traffic on streets surrounding the property as well as the types of properties in its vicinity.

Schools

Nearest elementary schools

Name Rating Type Grade range No of students Distance (miles)
Shelter Island School 5 Public PK, K-12 174 1.62
Shelter Island School 5 Public PK, K-12 174 1.62
Greenport Elementary School 3 Public PK, K-6 339 3.04
Greenport Elementary School 3 Public PK, K-6 339 3.04
Southold Elementary School 7 Public K-6 317 3.42
Sag Harbor Elementary School 5 Public PK, K-5 426 5.85
Sag Harbor Elementary School 5 Public PK, K-5 426 5.85
Mattituck Cutchogue Elementary School 6 Public K-6 453 5.89
Our Lady Of Mercy Regional School NR Private PK-6 92 6.89
Our Lady Of Mercy Regional School NR Private PK-6 92 6.89
Nearest middle schools

Name Rating Type Grade range No of students Distance (miles)
Shelter Island School 5 Public PK, K-12 174 1.62
Greenport High School 5 Public 7-12 356 3.04
Southold Junior Senior High School 5 Public 7-12 380 3.42
Pierson Middle High School 5 Public 6-12 525 5.97
The Hayground School NR Private PK-8 77 8.43
Ross School NR Private PK-12 312 8.93
Ross School NR Private PK-12 318 8.93
Bridgehampton School 7 Public PK, K-12 198 9.08
Mattituck Junior Senior High School 6 Public 7-12 548 9.46
Nearest high schools

Name Rating Type Grade range No of students Distance (miles)
Shelter Island School 5 Public PK, K-12 174 1.62
Greenport High School 5 Public 7-12 356 3.04
Southold Junior Senior High School 5 Public 7-12 380 3.42
Pierson Middle High School 5 Public 6-12 525 5.97
Ross School NR Private PK-12 312 8.93
Ross School NR Private PK-12 318 8.93
Bridgehampton School 7 Public PK, K-12 198 9.08
Mattituck Junior Senior High School 6 Public 7-12 548 9.46

Data provided by GreatSchools.org © 2026. All rights reserved.

Neighbors for 5 Worthy Way, Shelter Island, NY

3 Worthy Way, Shelter Island 11 Pennys Path, Shelter Island 1 Worthy Way, Shelter Island 21 Tims Trl, Shelter Island 9 Worthy Way, Shelter Island 42 Westmoreland Dr, Shelter Island 13 Pennys Path, Shelter Island 7 Worthy Way, Shelter Island 19 Tims Trl, Shelter Island 15 Pennys Path, Shelter Island 11 Worthy Way, Shelter Island Heights 13 Worthy Way, Shelter Island 11 Tims Trl, Shelter Island 3 Ole Buck Run, Shelter Island 9 Pennys Path, Shelter Island 15 Tims Trl, Shelter Island 16 Worthy Way, Shelter Island 13 Tims Trl, Shelter Island 7 Pennys Path, Shelter Island 17 Tims Trl, Shelter Island

Nearby ZIP codes for 5 Worthy Way, Shelter Island, NY

11930, Suffolk County, NY 11932, Suffolk County, NY 11935, Suffolk County, NY 11937, Suffolk County, NY 11939, Suffolk County, NY 11946, Suffolk County, NY 11947, Suffolk County, NY 11948, Suffolk County, NY 11952, Suffolk County, NY 11956, Suffolk County, NY 11957, Suffolk County, NY 11958, Suffolk County, NY 11962, Suffolk County, NY 11963, Suffolk County, NY 11965, Suffolk County, NY 11968, Suffolk County, NY 11971, Suffolk County, NY 11975, Suffolk County, NY 11976, Suffolk County, NY

Frequently asked questions

What is the year built for 5 Worthy Way, Shelter Island, NY 11964?

The development at 5 Worthy Way, Shelter Island, NY 11964 was built in 1977.

What is the total square footage of 5 Worthy Way, Shelter Island, NY 11964?

5 Worthy Way, Shelter Island, NY 11964 has a total of 1,281 square feet.

When was 5 Worthy Way, Shelter Island, NY 11964 last sold and what was the sale price?

5 Worthy Way, Shelter Island, NY 11964 was last sold on 05/07/2020 for $280,000.

What is the assessed value of 5 Worthy Way, Shelter Island, NY 11964?

5 Worthy Way, Shelter Island, NY 11964 is currently assessed at $1,062,000.

What are the property taxes for 5 Worthy Way, Shelter Island, NY 11964?

The property taxes for 5 Worthy Way, Shelter Island, NY 11964 total $4,441.

Disclaimer

Copyright 2003-2026 by PropertyShark.com

All data comes from government sources. No attempt has been made to validate it. No attempt has been made to validate the accuracy of the programming of this website.

Do not rely on this report to support investment decisions. The only authoritative source for the information in this report is the government agencies from which the data was acquired.

Sign up for a free account