Shirley, NY Housing Market Trends

Market Overview for Q3 2026

$535K -0.9% Y-o-Y -$5K Y-o-Y
$363 -1.4% Y-o-Y -$5 Y-o-Y
50 -55.4% Y-o-Y -62 Y-o-Y
$830K 33% Y-o-Y $208K Y-o-Y
Shirley, NY Median Sale Price
Year Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4
2022 $383,000 $408,000 $392,000 $401,000
2023 $400,000 $428,000 $440,000 $455,000
2024 $440,000 $475,000 $500,000 $500,000
2025 $503,000 $500,000 $540,000 $513,000
2026 $505,000 0 $535,000
Shirley, NY Median Sale Price/Sq. Ft.
Year Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4
2022 0 0 0 0
2023 0 0 0 0
2024 0 0 0 0
2025 0 0 $368 $374
2026 $353 0 $363
Real Estate Transactions in Shirley, NY
Year Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4
2022 138 114 144 117
2023 72 97 94 95
2024 58 57 106 83
2025 91 93 112 100
2026 140 0 50
Suffolk County Median Sale Price
Year Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4
2022 $525,000 $550,000 $555,000 $548,000
2023 $530,000 $560,000 $585,000 $599,000
2024 $590,000 $640,000 $650,000 $650,000
2025 $645,000 $670,000 $687,000 $685,000
2026 $676,000 $723,000 $695,000
Shirley, NY Median Sale Price
Year Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4
2022 $383,000 $408,000 $392,000 $401,000
2023 $400,000 $428,000 $440,000 $455,000
2024 $440,000 $475,000 $500,000 $500,000
2025 $503,000 $500,000 $540,000 $513,000
2026 $505,000 0 $535,000
Shirley, NY Median Sale Price/Sq. Ft.
Year Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4
2022 0 0 0 0
2023 0 0 0 0
2024 0 0 0 0
2025 0 0 $368 $374
2026 $353 0 $363
Real Estate Transactions in Shirley, NY
Year Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4
2022 138 114 144 117
2023 72 97 94 95
2024 58 57 106 83
2025 91 93 112 100
2026 140 0 50
Suffolk County Median Sale Price
Year Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4
2022 $525,000 $550,000 $555,000 $548,000
2023 $530,000 $560,000 $585,000 $599,000
2024 $590,000 $640,000 $650,000 $650,000
2025 $645,000 $670,000 $687,000 $685,000
2026 $676,000 $723,000 $695,000

Median Sale Price by Number of Bedrooms

Shirley, NY Housing Stock

Property Type
Units
Single Family
8,061
2-4 Family
100
Condo
172
Townhouse
34
Other
50

Suffolk County: Demographics

Total population
28,375
Median age
40.3
No high school education
6.6%
Some high school/college
42.4%
Bachelor's degree
12.4%
Average household income
$164,112
Occupied housing units
8,483
Owner-occupied units
92.2%
Renter-occupied units
7.8%
Median year structure built
1975

Discover Housing Market Trends in Other Cities

#
City
Median Sale Price
1
Sag Harbor
$3M
2
Southampton
$2.4M
3
Hampton Bays
$898K
4
East Islip
$850K
5
Manorville
$755K
6
Commack
$745K
7
Smithtown
$738K
8
Saint James
$730K
9
West Islip
$706K
10
Sayville
$705K
11
Kings Park
$695K
12
Holbrook
$675K
13
Babylon
$665K
14
Deer Park
$650K
15
Riverhead
$650K
16
West Babylon
$643K
17
North Babylon
$638K
18
Lindenhurst
$635K
19
Islip
$632K
20
Bay Shore
$632K
21
Ronkonkoma
$630K
22
Brentwood
$625K
23
Centereach
$615K
24
Amityville
$608K
25
Copiague
$603K
26
Farmingville
$600K
28
Central Islip
$578K
29
Patchogue
$575K
30
Wyandanch
$575K
31
Selden
$565K
32
Medford
$550K
33
Coram
$525K
34
Ridge
$479K
35
Mastic
$470K
36
Middle Island
$428K