• Property Lists
  • Listings
    • Commercial Real Estate
  • Comparables
  • Owners
  • Maps
  • Resources
    • Learning Center
    • Blog
Add a Listing Advertise
  1. Commercial Properties
  2. NY
  3. Ithaca

123 E Buffalo St

For Sale

123 E Buffalo St, Ithaca, NY 14850

123-125 E Buffalo St and N Cayuga123–125 East Buffalo Street | Downtown Ithaca Commercial & Parking Investment Opportunity Rare opportunity to acquire a strategically positioned two-parcel commercial assemblage in the heart of Downtown Ithaca, within easy walking distance of the Ithaca Commons and surrounded by hotels, restaurants, retail, offices, entertainment and downtown destinations. 123–125 East Buffalo Street features a 264± SF former bank drive-through kiosk together with an adjacent 0.22± acre paved parking lot. The combined property currently provides approximately 18 parking spaces, established curb cuts and existing drive-through infrastructure in a highly walkable downtown location where dedicated off-street parking is a valuable and increasingly scarce amenity. Significant Parking & Income Potential In addition to continued use of the existing improvements, the property presents a compelling opportunity for an investor or operator focused on downtown parking. Removal of the small existing kiosk could potentially allow the site to be reconfigured to accommodate approximately 28 parking spaces, subject to final layout, municipal approvals and existing easements. The property's location within walking distance of the Ithaca Commons, downtown businesses, restaurants, hotels and other commercial destinations creates an opportunity to explore a cash-flowing surface parking operation serving multiple sources of downtown parking demand. Potential revenue strategies could include monthly contract parking, employee and business parking, hotel-related parking arrangements, and daily or transient parking. With a relatively small existing structure, a purchaser can evaluate the economics of maintaining the current commercial configuration or removing the kiosk and maximizing the property's parking capacity and income potential. The property's CBD-85 zoning further enhances its long-term strategic value, making this a particularly unusual opportunity to control a two-parcel assemblage with dedicated parking in Downtown Ithaca. Property Highlights Downtown Ithaca location Easy walking distance to the Ithaca Commons Two contiguous parcels offered as one assemblage 264± SF former bank drive-through kiosk 0.22± acre adjacent paved parking lot for a total of .29 Acres Approximately 18 existing parking spaces Potential for approximately 28 spaces through removal of the existing kiosk and site reconfiguration Potential cash-flowing surface parking investment Opportunity for monthly, contract and transient parking strategies Existing curb cuts and established vehicular access CBD-85 zoning Strong pedestrian and vehicular accessibility Surrounded by hotels, restaurants, offices, retail and downtown amenities Potential appeal to investors, owner-users and neighboring property owners The property is subject to recorded access and utility easements benefiting the adjacent hotel. Any parking reconfiguration, redevelopment or change in use should be independently evaluated by the purchaser and is subject to applicable municipal approvals and existing easement rights. Drive-through food and beverage uses are not permitted under current City of Ithaca zoning.

Building Details

  • For Sale $400,000
  • Property Type Retail - Street Retail
  • Property Size 264 SF
  • Units 1
  • Lot Size 0.07 Acre
  • Additional Rent Price on request
  • Property Tenancy Single Tenant
  • Building Class C
  • Year Built 1990
  • Date Updated Aug 26, 2026
Want more info on this listing?

Reach out to the broker for more info on lease terms and amenities

False

Contacts

broker
Steven Reed

HUNT Commercial

Location

  • City Ithaca, NY
  • Neighborhood Downtown Ithaca
  • Zip Code 14850
  • Map
  • Street
  • Walk score 96/100 Walker's Paradise
  • Bike score 90/100 Biker's Paradise
Powered by Walk Score ®

Points of Interest

Citgo

0.44 miles

Mobil

0.55 miles

Fastrac

0.56 miles

Sunoco

0.86 miles

Kwik Fill

1.07 miles

Byrne Dairy & Deli

1.26 miles

Mirabito

1.73 miles

BJ’s Gas

3.18 miles

ChargePoint

8.75 miles

Seneca Street Garage

0.07 miles

Green Street Parking Garage

0.16 miles

Cayuga Street Parking Garage

0.26 miles

Dryden Rd Garage

0.57 miles

Gannett Lot

0.67 miles

Willard Straight Lot

0.70 miles

Gun Hill Residence Parking

0.74 miles

Cornell Police Parking

0.91 miles

U

0.93 miles

Hoy Road Garage

0.95 miles

GreenStar Food Co+op

0.05 miles

Green Castle Asian Market

0.53 miles

GreenStar Natural Foods Market

0.64 miles

Anabel's Grocery

0.66 miles

Greenstar Food Co+op @ Cascadilla

0.69 miles

Ren's Mart

0.69 miles

ALDI

0.74 miles

Wegmans

0.75 miles

Ithaca Shopping Plaza

0.91 miles

TJ Maxx

1.07 miles

Listing Summary

  • What is the asking price at 123 E Buffalo St?

    123 E Buffalo St is currently listed for sale at Price on request.

  • What is the total size of 123 E Buffalo St?

    123 E Buffalo St has a total of 264 square feet.

  • What is the year built for 123 E Buffalo St?

    The year built for 123 E Buffalo St is 1990.

Contact Steven Reed
broker
Steven Reed

HUNT Commercial

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Nearby Listings

602 West State Street

602 West State Street

602 West State Street, Ithaca, NY
$1,500,000
Property
  • Retail
  • 5,628 SF

Popular Searches

  • Syracuse Retail Properties for Sale
  • Binghamton Retail Properties for Sale
  • Rochester Retail Properties for Sale
  • Syracuse Commercial Real Estate
  • Binghamton Commercial Real Estate
  • Rochester Commercial Real Estate
  • Cortland Commercial Real Estate
  • Endicott Commercial Real Estate
  • Auburn Commercial Real Estate
  • Elmira Commercial Real Estate
  • Horseheads Commercial Real Estate
  • Ithaca Commercial Real Estate
  • Johnson City Commercial Real Estate
  • Blog
  • X
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • About
  • Our Services
  • Contact Us
  • Sitemaps
  • Privacy Policy
  • Your CA Privacy Rights
  • Terms Of Service
  • FAQ

Customer Service

  • (718)715-1758
  • Contact us
Copyright 2003-2026, PropertyShark.com