West Wayne Plaza

For Sale

1900 New York 31, Macedon, NY 14502

West Wayne Plaza is on NY-31 in Macedon, a key corridor linking Canandaigua, Palmyra, and Rochester. It offers multiple access points and is minutes from Route 350, NYS Route 441, I-490, and I-90. Just 20 miles from downtown Rochester, the area is anchored by Walmart and Lowe’s, with strong traffic and a growing residential base.This 93,748 SF shopping center is 98% occupied, with below market rents offering a clear opportunity to increase NOI. Zoned Canal Corridor Overlay District/General Commercial, the property supports a wide range of retail and service uses. The building features a flexible layout and strong tenant mix, making it ideal for a retail or neighborhood center investor. With stable occupancy, upside potential, and a substantial footprint, this property is a compelling investment in a proven commercial setting.

Key features

  • 38,000+ residents within a 5-mile radius; high daily vehicle count on NY-31.
  • 502’ Frontage on Route 31
  • Close to Walmart, Wegmans, Lowe’s, Macedon Commons, schools, and Erie Canal
  • Concrete and steel construction, large storefront windows, flexible layouts, and pylon
  • Occupied by a mix of regional and local tenants; strong income with upside through lease-up or redevelopment.
  • recreation.
  • signage.

Building Details

  • For Sale $5,500,000
  • Property Type Retail
  • Property Size 93,748 SF
  • Lot Size 12.05 Acre
  • Additional Rent Price on request
  • Property Tenancy Multi-Tenant
  • Date Updated Oct 5, 2026
View Attachment
Want more info on this listing?

Reach out to the broker for more info on lease terms and amenities

Contacts

Daniel Bosio

Caliber Commercial Brokerage

Location

  • City Macedon, NY
  • Zip Code 14502
  • Market Rochester
  • Walk score 20/100 Car-Dependent
  • Bike score 43/100 Somewhat Bikeable
Powered by Walk Score ®

Points of Interest

Speedway

0.47 miles

Marathon

3.16 miles

Mobil

3.18 miles

Byrne Dairy

3.43 miles

Kwik Fill

3.67 miles

Gulf

3.69 miles

Tops

4.87 miles

Exxon

6.19 miles

Tesla Supercharger

8.19 miles

Harris Whalen Park Vehicle Charging Station

9.15 miles

Southeast Parking Lot

0.84 miles

Southwest Parking Lot

0.91 miles

PCC Parking

2.47 miles

Interchange 44 - Canandaigua Park and Ride Lot

6.77 miles

Public Parking

7.14 miles

Sherwood Park - Parking Lot

7.48 miles

Perinton Park and Ride

7.62 miles

Fairport Central School District Bus Depot

7.71 miles

Fairport Junction

8.07 miles

Walmart Supercenter

3.55 miles

Tops

4.80 miles

ALDI

7.52 miles

Perinton Square Mall

7.68 miles

Wegmans

7.99 miles

Bliss Shurfine Food Mart

8.02 miles

TJ Maxx

8.02 miles

Red Bird Market

8.12 miles

Fairport Village Landing

8.14 miles

Macy's

8.28 miles

Listing Summary

  • Property Financials

    1900 New York 31 is currently listed for sale at $5,500,000 for a price per square foot of $58.67.

  • Property Details

    1900 New York 31 totals 93,748 square feet of Retail space on a lot spanning 12.05 acres.

    Tenancy at 1900 New York 31 is listed as Multi-Tenant.

  • Area Characteristics

    In terms of ease of commuting, the area has a walk score of 20, indicating that it is car-dependent.

Contact Daniel Bosio
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.