Featured 960x640-3 (1)

| 7 minute read

How to Find Off-Market Properties: A Step-by-Step Guide for Real Estate Professionals 

By Laura McGregor | Sep 18, 2025

Off-market properties can give brokers, investors and other real estate professionals looking for more opportunities a real competitive edge. Explore this step-by-step guide to learn how to find off-market properties quickly and efficiently with PropertyShark.

What Are Off-Market Properties and How Are They Different from Listed Properties? 

Off-market properties are real estate assets that are not publicly listed for sale on platforms like the MLS (Multiple Listing Service) or public listing websites. These properties may still be owned by motivated sellers, long-term holders or distressed owners, but require more effort to discover. Off-market sales happen privately, either through direct negotiation between the seller and buyer or through an agent or broker that facilitates the deal.  

For real estate professionals like brokers and investors, knowing how to find off-market properties is essential since it creates additional opportunities and provides a competitive edge. In fact, a survey of real estate investors found that 40% bought their most recent property off-market, which goes to highlight a significant share that remains underexplored even in dynamic markets like NYC real estate. 

How to Find Off-Market Properties 

While the benefits of targeting unlisted real estate are clear, finding off-market properties can be challenging. Public sources are free but often require manual research to uncover the actual owners, while paid platforms simplify the process by providing verified ownership and contact details in one place. 

Free Methods: 

  • NYC ACRIS: deed and mortgage documents 
  • NYC DOB: permits, violations, listed owner info 
  • NY State DOS: business entity searches for LLCs 
  • On-site canvassing: building signage, staff conversations 
  • Word of mouth: networking, professional and personal relationships 

Paid Tools: 

PropertyShark: Consolidates ownership data, shows both LLCs and the true owners behind them, provides contact info and advanced search filters. PropertyShark provides a comprehensive and easy-to-use platform that includes in-depth details on both listed and off-market properties, with 100% coverage in NYC. Here’s a simple, proven method to discover off-market leads on PropertyShark using our advanced filters and Property Lists tool.

Find Off-Market Assets with PropertyShark: A Step-by-Step Guide

Step 1: Log into PropertyShark 

Visit PropertyShark.com and sign in with your account. If you’re not a subscriber yet, you can create a free account and preview one full property report which will help you get started with how to find off-market properties. 

Step 2: Use the Search Tool 

Navigate to the Search bar under the Properties tab. Enter your location of interest and choose from a wide range of filters to narrow down your search: 

  • Property type  
  • Square footage 
  • Year built 
  • Sales history  

Tip: To increase your chances of finding a motivated seller, select properties that haven’t sold in 10+ years. 

For the best results, look for properties with no recent sale activity and no listing status. These are most likely to be off-market assets. 

Step 3: Check Ownership Details 

Click on any property from your results. You’ll see: 

  • The registered owner’s name, often an LLC 
  • Real owner info, when available, including their full name, phone number, email, and mailing address 

Step 4: Build a Property List 

Use the Property Lists tool to: 

  • Save your filtered search results 
  • Export ownership and contact data to a PDF or spreadsheet 
  • Create targeted prospecting campaigns for outreach 

Which Distress Signals Point to Motivated Sellers?

When trying to pinpoint motivated sellers to land an off-market deal, there are a few relevant clues regarding the state of the property or the status of the owner that can help:

Notice of default or lis pendens filing

A notice of default or lis pendens filing signals that an owner has fallen behind on mortgage payments and that foreclosure proceedings may be underway. In New York, where foreclosures go through the courts, a lis pendens is typically the first public sign. Owners at this stage may prefer a quick private sale to avoid foreclosure, making them highly motivated. You can learn more about how to find foreclosed homes even before they’re widely listed and specifically, how to find foreclosures in NYC or nationwide.

Tax delinquency

Unpaid property taxes often point to financial strain or an owner who has lost interest in the property. Delinquent owners may face penalties, interest or a tax lien sale, which can make a direct offer an attractive way out. Tax delinquency is especially telling when combined with other signs of neglect.

Code violations

Open building code violations, such as those recorded by the NYC Department of Buildings, can signal deferred maintenance or an owner unable or unwilling to fund repairs. Multiple or long-standing violations add costs and fines that some owners would rather pass on to a buyer.

Long ownership with high equity

Owners who have held a property for 10 years or more often have significant equity, giving them flexibility on price and fewer obstacles to selling. Long-term owners may also be approaching life changes such as retirement, downsizing or estate planning.

Absentee owner

An absentee owner is one whose mailing address differs from the property address, meaning they don’t live in the property they own. Out-of-area owners, inherited properties and tired landlords fall into this group and may be more open to selling, especially if managing the property has become a burden. Comparing the owner’s mailing address with the property address in ownership records reveals absentee ownership quickly. Read more about the quickest and most effective ways to find absentee owners, how to contact them and how to successfully close deals.

Vacant property

Vacant properties generate costs, such as taxes, insurance and maintenance, without producing income, which can motivate owners to sell. Signs of vacancy include boarded windows, accumulated mail, overgrown lots and a lack of utility activity. On-site canvassing remains one of the most reliable ways to confirm vacancy.

Combine Signals for the Strongest Leads

A single distress signal suggests potential motivation, but properties showing two or more signals are the strongest leads to contact first. An absentee owner with a vacant building, for example, or a long-held property with tax delinquency and open violations, points to an owner with both the reason and the flexibility to sell. Using PropertyShark’s filters and Property Lists tool, professionals can stack these criteria to build a prioritized outreach list.

How to Verify If an Off-Market Deal Is Legitimate

When assessing an off-market deal, verifying the property and the seller before moving forward protects against title issues, hidden debts and fraud. These four steps help confirm that an off-market opportunity is legitimate:

  1. Confirm the current owner of record. Start by checking who legally owns the property. Deeds and other recorded documents are typically available through public sources, while a PropertyShark property report adds another layer to the due diligence process by showing the registered owner alongside the full sales and ownership history. Before moving forward with a potential deal, make sure that the person offering the deal matches the owner of record.
  2. Check for active filings. Review the property report for liens, lis pendens filings, mortgages and open violations. These can affect the price, delay closing or transfer costs and liabilities to the buyer. A lis pendens, for example, signals pending litigation tied to the property, which must be resolved before the title can transfer cleanly.
  3. Identify the real owner behind an LLC. Many NYC properties are held by LLCs, which can make it hard to know who you’re actually dealing with. Business entity records from the NY State Department of State provide a starting point, while PropertyShark’s Real Owners feature reveals the individuals behind ownership entities when available. Confirming the real owner helps ensure the person negotiating has the authority to sell.
  4. Contact the owner directly. Whenever possible, reach out to the verified owner yourself rather than relying on an unverified intermediary. Direct contact confirms that the owner actually intends to sell, reduces the risk of misrepresented terms and helps avoid paying unnecessary fees to middlemen. PropertyShark provides owner contact information, including phone numbers, emails and mailing addresses, to make that outreach easier.

What Are the Key Features of PropertyShark’s Off-Market Search Tools? 

PropertyShark supports professionals looking to learn how to find off-market properties through the following key features: 

  • True owner identification: Unmasks LLCs to reveal individuals behind ownership entities. 
  • Verified contact information: Includes phone numbers, emails and mailing addresses. 
  • Consolidated reports: Sales history, zoning, permits, violations and comps, all in one place. 
  • Property Lists tool: Build, save, and export lead lists for outreach. 
  • Interactive maps and filters: Visually canvass neighborhoods for high-potential properties. 

Create a free account now

No credit card required. Full details and history for one property.

What Are the Advantages of Off-Market Properties for Real Estate Professionals? 

While listed properties are typically the bread and butter of real estate professionals looking to sell or buy, finding off-market properties gives real estate professionals a strategic edge. Many agents, brokers and investors prefer targeting properties with high potential that are not yet on the market but have significant deal potential if the seller is motivated enough and receives a fair evaluation.  

The main reason why real estate professionals leverage off-market properties as additional revenue sources is that they can provide: 

  • Less competition: These properties aren’t being widely marketed, which means other brokerages or buyers are not competing for the listing. 
  • Better deals: Sellers may be more flexible on pricing since they won’t have to deal with the hassle of a large public and several agencies. 
  • Direct access to owners: Ideal for brokers, investors and developers seeking exclusive opportunities that will give them a competitive advantage. 

FAQs About Off-Market Properties 

What qualifies a property as off-market?  

An off-market property is a property not currently listed for sale on the MLS or public listing websites. 

Can I find off-market properties without paying for a tool?  

Yes, you can find off-market properties without paid tools, but it typically involves time-intensive cross-referencing across public records like ACRIS, DOB, and the NYS Department of State. 

How accurate is the ownership data in PropertyShark?  

Ownership data accuracy is essential: PropertyShark provides verified owner contact info, including LLC unmasking, which is not available through public sources alone. PropertyShark obtains property information only from official and vetted NYC real estate data sources such as government agencies and employs significant property research efforts to verify the validity of property data. 

Who benefits most from using PropertyShark to find off-market properties? 

Investors, brokers, developers and anyone pursuing off-market deals for acquisition, development or outreach can benefit from using PropertyShark. 

Can I try PropertyShark without subscribing?  

Yes, you can sign up for a free PropertyShark account and preview one full property ownership report. 

What percentage of real estate deals happen off-market?  

40% of real estate investors who participated in a recent industry survey said that they bought their last property off-market.

Do off-market properties sell for less than listed properties?  

Yes, research indicates off-market properties typically sell for $4,975 less on average, with MLS listings commanding 13-20% higher prices.   

How do I find NYC pre-foreclosures with owner contact information?

PropertyShark users can find properties in pre-foreclosure by accessing the dedicated Foreclosures tab in the platform’s menu. Under NYC Pre-Foreclosures, users can open property reports and see detailed property details, including ownership and contact information.


About PropertyShark

PropertyShark is an online real estate database and property research tool that provides building details, ownership information, comparable sales and foreclosure data. Founded in 2003, PropertyShark serves real estate professionals and consumers in New York and other major U.S. markets.

Fair Use & Redistribution  

We encourage and freely grant permission to reuse and repost information, analysis, charts, tables and images included on this page. When doing so, we only ask that you link back to this page or PropertyShark.com as the official source. 

Disclaimer

Information provided on this page is purely informational and is not and should not be regarded as investment advice. 

Table of Contents
    Add a header to begin generating the table of contents

    Want to stay on top of the real estate market?

    Access comprehensive property data and ownership information with intuitive research tools.

    Laura McGregor is a Senior Creative Writer at PropertyShark, with a degree in Journalism and a background in both hospitality and real estate. Laura is a certified bookworm with a genuine passion for the written word and a keen interest in the real estate market, having previously written for Yardi's RentCafe, CoworkingCafe and CoworkingMag. Her work has been featured in major publications like The New York Times, Forbes, NBC News, The Business Journals, Chicago Tribune, MSN and Yahoo! Finance, among others.

    Recent Reports

    A Decade of Homeownership Trends Across NYC Neighborhoods: Where Owners Gained Ground & Where Renters Took Over 
    November 17, 2026

    Shifts in homeownership trends led Manhattan to record the highest increase in the share of owner-occupied homes, while Staten Island stood out as the only NYC borough where renters gained ground over the past decade.

    2026 Q3 Foreclosure Report: NYC Foreclosure Activity Slows to 4-Year Low, Fueled by Queens & Brooklyn Contractions
    October 22, 2026

    NYC foreclosures contracted to levels not seen since late 2022, fueled by drops in Brooklyn and Queens. Meanwhile, elevated activity in the Bronx kept it near the forefront, surpassed only by Queens.

    Atherton Breaks $10M Median as 11 States Set New Price Records
    October 13, 2026

    2026 brought record price peaks to 11 states, including the first ever eight-figure median sale price with Atherton’s dramatic surge back to #1. Meanwhile, California’s presence continued to shrink with the pullback of the Bay Area, although it remained home to more than half of the country’s top zips, while the New York metro supplied one quarter, its strongest presence yet.