Coney Island Real Estate Market Trends

Market Overview for Quarter 1, 2023

Median Sale Price


-6.7% YoY

Median Price/Sqft


-22.1% YoY

No. of Transactions


-50.9% YoY

Brooklyn Median Sale Price


-5% YoY

What is the median sale price and median price per sq ft in Coney Island?

In Quarter 1, the median home sale price in Coney Island was $429K, down 6.7% year-over-year. There were a total of 26 transactions, representing a 50.9% drop compared to Quarter 1 last year. The median price per square foot was $424, a -22.1% YoY change. In Quarter 1, the median home sale price in Brooklyn was $755K.

Coney Island Median Sale Price

View: GraphTable

Median Sale Price Per Square Feet

View: Graph Table

Real Estate Transactions in Coney Island

View: Graph Table

Top most expensive neighborhoods in Brooklyn

Coney Island median price compared with other neighborhoods in Brooklyn

Property values in Coney Island are lower compared to the borough of Coney Island overall.

Coney Island median price compared with all the neighborhoods in Brooklyn

Neighborhood Borough Median Sale Price
Red Hook Brooklyn $2,865,000
DUMBO Brooklyn $1,798,696
Carroll Gardens Brooklyn $1,633,371
Gowanus Brooklyn $1,600,000
Williamsburg Brooklyn $1,400,000
Vinegar Hill Brooklyn $1,290,400
Downtown Brooklyn Brooklyn $1,256,087
Park Slope Brooklyn $1,207,500
Columbia Street Waterfront District Brooklyn $1,114,828
Brooklyn Heights Brooklyn $1,093,878
Greenpoint Brooklyn $1,080,750
Fiske Terrace Brooklyn $1,080,000
Cobble Hill Brooklyn $1,055,000
Greenwood Heights Brooklyn $1,049,000
Prospect Heights Brooklyn $1,010,000
Clinton Hill Brooklyn $975,000
Boerum Hill Brooklyn $971,396
Manhattan Beach Brooklyn $933,628
Bergen Beach Brooklyn $924,197
Borough Park Brooklyn $922,500
Crown Heights Brooklyn $888,030
Dyker Heights Brooklyn $876,500
Mill Basin Brooklyn $865,000
Bedford-Stuyvesant Brooklyn $842,500
Madison Brooklyn $818,000
Windsor Terrace Brooklyn $805,000
Flatbush Brooklyn $800,000
Marine Park Brooklyn $734,250
Wingate Brooklyn $692,000
Prospect - Lefferts Gardens Brooklyn $675,000
Prospect Park South Brooklyn $675,000
Bath Beach Brooklyn $665,000
Bay Ridge Brooklyn $654,500
Midwood Brooklyn $644,821
Georgetown Brooklyn $640,380
East Flatbush Brooklyn $638,600
Bushwick Brooklyn $637,406
Fort Greene Brooklyn $623,350
Gravesend Brooklyn $619,500
Bensonhurst Brooklyn $605,500
Gerritsen Beach Brooklyn $567,500
Ocean Hill Brooklyn $553,731
Kensington Brooklyn $551,750
Brownsville Brooklyn $541,667
Canarsie Brooklyn $520,000
Sea Gate Brooklyn $517,500
Sunset Park Brooklyn $475,000
Ditmas Park Brooklyn $457,500
East New York Brooklyn $447,500
Coney Island Brooklyn $429,000
Flatlands Brooklyn $427,500
Brighton Beach Brooklyn $420,000
Homecrest Brooklyn $410,000
Old Mill Basin Brooklyn $400,000
Sheepshead Bay Brooklyn $340,000

Residential Properties Sold in Coney Island

Property Type Median sale price Y-o-Y Median sale price/sqft Y-o-Y Transactions
Condos $561K -9.1% $723 12% 2
Coops $385K -6.1% $411 -4.5% 18
Houses $585K -3.9% $377 -3.1% 6

The median house sale price in Coney Island in Quarter 1 was $585K, down 3.9% year-over-year. Condo and coop prices in Coney Island trended similarly, with a median condo price of $561K, down 9.1% year-over-year, and the median coop sale price down -6.1 % year-over-year to $385K.

See also

Fair use and redistribution

We encourage and freely grant you permission to reuse and repost the information, charts and images found in this report. When doing so, we only ask that you link back to this page, or